Skip to content

Defense questions legality of drug arrest

Did a deputy go too far when he stepped inside a suspected pot smoker’s home without a warrant or invitation to bust him for marijuana possession? The court says no.
The suspect, James E. Bauma II, was issued a six-month judicial diversion by General Sessions Judge Larry Ross and must pay a $250 fine, as well as perform 16 hours public service work for simple possession of marijuana. His sentence came after a preliminary hearing before the court during which defense attorney Steve Roller maintained deputy Travis Thaxton went too far by entering the suspect’s home given the fact he should not have even been at his door in the first place.
Thaxton explained while on the witness stand that he was looking for another individual on whom he had a warrant to serve and had mistakenly gone to Bauma’s door while in the apartment complex. During his short visit, in which Bauma told Thaxton that the man he was looking for was not here, Thaxton said he smelled the unmistakable odor of marijuana.
‘I smelled a strong smell of what I believed to be marijuana,’ Thaxton said of the odor hanging in the air when the door was opened.
Bauma denied any knowledge at first, but then admitted he had smoked some and offered to go get it for the officer. It was at that point Thaxton followed Bauma through the door as he retrieved the tray of marijuana from a couch. Thaxton said he stepped in for his own safety, in case Bauma went for a weapon instead of the marijuana. However, Roller maintained Thaxton should not have even been at his client’s home in the first place.
‘You are at the wrong place talking to the wrong person and then you give him the third degree,’ said Roller, asking the court to throw out the case against Bauma.
Bauma maintained he felt intimidated into getting the marijuana, plus his wife testified that Thaxton had threatened to have their children, who were at home at the time, taken away by DCS if he did not comply with handing over the marijuana.
However, Judge Ross, while admitting the incident gave him pause for thought, said the officer was in the right if he merely followed the suspect inside to make sure he was not going to return with a weapon.
‘It’s a close call, but what is he supposed to do’? asked Ross, saying he felt credibility was also an issue as to how the incident happened. ‘It’s hard for me to believe this officer would lie under oath just to get a conviction on a simple possession case.’

Leave a Comment