Skip to content

Lawmakers should tighten excess sales tax exemptions

When state revenue plummets, as it’s doing right now, there are always cries for our state government to implement a different form of taxation.

The sales tax is subject to broad fluctuations, which is great during robust economic times but a nightmare when spending comes to a halt. Thus, there are calls for the state to revisit alternate forms of funding.

While this idea has merits, it also has one fundamental problem. Tennesseans have said, time and time again, they don’t want any sort of income tax ‘ period. Thus we appear stuck with our sales tax system, warts and all.

But the state doesn’t have to look outside the sales tax to generate the revenue it needs. There are dozens and dozens of sales tax exemptions that can be eliminated that will generate millions of dollars for Tennessee.

In fact, if you look at Gov. Phil Bredesen’s proposed $28 billion budget for the 2008-09 fiscal year, there is $3 billion in projected losses due to sales tax exemptions. That’s nearly 10 percent of the total budget, and six times the estimated $500 million Bredesen says must be cut.

Eliminating sales tax exemptions would be the fairest way for the state to conduct business. Why should church groups and non-profit organizations, for example, be given a free ride when it comes to sales tax? Why should building contractors be exempt from paying sales tax on their supplies? Why shouldn’t their be sales tax on a haircut?

When some groups pay sales tax, while others do not, it’s easy to make the claim our state government is playing favorites. And it makes the organizations who are forced to pay sales tax lobby hard to be included on the tax-exempt list. Lawmakers are bombarded by annual requests from groups wanting to be free from the burden of sales tax ‘ and who can blame them.

With the state looking to buyout some 2,000 longtime employees, cut its programs, and possibly dip into its rainy day fund, there is reason for concern. But this concern, in large part, could have been eliminated if there weren’t so many sales tax exemptions.

The governor and our state legislators will be making some tough decisions in the coming days and weeks. Funding cuts and job losses are not enjoyable topics.

For the good of everyone, and for the benefit of the state, we can at least learn something from this fiasco.Tennessee’s tax system, for all its convenience, is badly flawed. Eliminating some of the sales tax exceptions is one fix ‘ without the burden of a dreaded state income tax.

Leave a Comment