Juries return solid verdicts
You’d be hard pressed to find an attorney who savors a jury trial. That’s because no matter how much proof is offered, no matter how much evidence is paraded into the courtroom, a jury is capable of doing anything.
In what I would consider a rarity, Warren County juries delivered two high-profile verdicts in a matter of two days. And while juries will often leave you scratching your head, I think both reached proper verdicts based on the evidence they heard.
Sherri Mathis, convicted Tuesday of first-degree murder, certainly faced an uphill battle in fighting for her freedom. I thought it would be a tough case for her coming in, and it only got worse as the case progressed.
I credit special prosecutor Brian Holmgren with doing a superb job. It could be pointed out the state had a tremendous case against Mathis, but we’ve seen other prosecutors trip over their feet in such instances, most notably in the Mary Winkler case.
Based on the evidence presented, jurors had an easy choice in delivering a guilty verdict against Mathis. Pictures of a badly bruised 6-year-old on an autopsy table had shock value that could not be overcome.
I believe jurors in the Heath Crisp and Kinsley Fisk rape case also made the right call in delivering not-guilty verdicts Wednesday night, based on the testimony that was heard. I had several people approach me and question this verdict yesterday, but I believe it was a sound one.
The main discrepancy most onlookers have pointed out is that Fisk and Crisp were allegedly part of a six-member group that ripped through a Martin Street home and terrorized a 23-year-old woman who was there. Four members of that group entered plea bargains and were given jail time. Fisk and Crisp did not enter pleas and are now free ‘ and without convictions.
It’s important to note the four people who took plea deals were all given less than a year in jail. If faced with a possible lengthy prison sentence if convicted, or less than one year in the county jail with a guilty plea, it might be tempting to take the plea, regardless of the circumstances.
Dustin Couch is a perfect example. He took a plea agreement and has already been released. He testified this week he has moved to another town and has started a new life.
Prosecutors weren’t willing to cut any such deal with Crisp and Fisk ‘ and rightfully so. If prosecutors believed the two were guilty of rape, you can’t allow them to walk free with a slap on the wrist. There would be outcry, most notably from me.
But without a plea, it also means the prosecution has the burden of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. That can be tricky when dealing with rape, which often comes down to a he-said, she-said situation.
When that’s the case, the so-called victim must be believable. The reported victim can’t admit to lying to investigators and then lying in earlier testimony under oath. That throws the victim’s credibility under the wheels of a fast-moving train. Without credibility, there is no rape case, or really any case at all.
If I was making predictions, I would have guessed the jury would dismiss the rape charge and possibly convict the two on a lesser offense since there didn’t appear to be too much resistance to an allegation that Crisp and Fisk entered the home against the women’s will.
But when credibility is shattered, it can be difficult to stop the proverbial bleeding. If the jury didn’t believe this woman was telling the truth ‘ and she gave them every reason to formulate that opinion ‘ not guilty is the proper verdict.
James Clark is editor of the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].
