Skip to content

Prosecutor ends case by urging jurors for justice

Prosecutor ends case by urging jurors for justice

Cheyenne Delp’s mother, Roxanne Haga, smiles after hearing the jury foreman announce guilty verdicts yesterday afternoon.
Saying the system failed Cheyenne Delp in not protecting her from abuse, special prosecutor Brian Holmgren urged jurors to finally give the 6-year-old justice by convicting her caregiver, Sherri Mathis, for her murder.

‘Cheyenne is uttering one more cry,’ Holmgren said in his final words during closing arguments Monday afternoon. ‘It’s a cry for justice.’

In asking for a guilty verdict against the former Small Wonders daycare owner, Holmgren noted the system failed to help Cheyenne Delp during her life, despite four referrals for alleged abuse, along with the reluctance of her own attending physician to declare her injuries the product of child abuse.

‘Dr. (Clifford) Seyler blew the call,’ Holmgren said of Cheyenne’s attending physician, who served as a defense expert during the trial and testified he did not think bruises he saw on the child were from child abuse. ‘The system failed Cheyenne miserably.’

‘His opinions matched his ego,’ Holmgren added of Dr. Seyler, noting he believed Mathis had tricked him into believing the child was mentally ill and needed medication without him personally verifying the child’s condition. ‘He was duped.’

While Holmgren painted a picture of long-term abuse at the hands of Mathis, her defense questioned the lack of motive in harming a child she had taken in to help. Specifically, defense attorney Michael Galligan questioned why a respected daycare professional, with no prior criminal record and mother of three, would suddenly become a killer, suggesting investigators wanted to pin the child’s death on someone.

‘There was mass hysteria in this community that Sherri Mathis must have done this,’ Galligan said, pointing out defense experts found toxic levels of psychiatric drugs in the child’s system ‘ drugs the defense believes caused the child’s death. ‘They didn’t look at all the evidence.’

Fellow defense attorney Jack Lowery accused Cheyenne’s older brothers, David and Ryan, of lying on the stand when they said they were beaten and choked by Mathis and they had seen their sister suffer similar abuse.

‘These young men were coached,’ Lowery said, indicating the boys, now young teens, had told investigators they felt safe with Mathis until they changed their story weeks after their sister’s death. Lowery suggested it was their mother who coached the boys.

‘What does she (Mathis) get for helping’? Lowery asked. ‘She gets arrested, indicted and now she’s looking at going to prison for a long time. This has been a rush to judgment.’

Holmgren resisted the rush to judgment claim, noting lawmen did not even know the child died from strangulation until the autopsy was released. Holmgren wondered how the boys could have been coached on saying they were choked by Mathis when no one yet knew she would face such an allegation.

‘This wasn’t a rush to judgment, it was a search for the truth,’ Holmgren said.

As for motive, Holmgren said only Mathis knows for sure.

‘One cannot give reason to the evil in the hearts of men,’ Holmgren told jurors, noting just because Mathis had no prior criminal record does not mean she was not capable of murder. ‘Every transgression, every sin, every crime, has a first time.’

Leave a Comment