Heart attack killed Delp, experts say-Dr. Walker testifies 6-year-old was prescribed deadly drug combination
|
‘I believe with all my heart this child died of torsade (heart attack),’ Dr. Walker testified Friday as the defense’s last witness in the Sherri Mathis murder trial. ‘Why were such toxic drugs allowed in a child that age’?
Dr. Walker’s testimony came as the trial against the former daycare owner and legal guardian of Cheyenne and her two older brothers ended.
Mathis is charged with strangling the child on the afternoon of June 26, 2004. Walker’s testimony offered an alternate cause of death than the strangulation claimed by forensic pathologist Dr. Bruce Levy.
Specifically, Dr. Walker told jurors the drugs prescribed by psychiatrist Dr. Saran Mudumbi of Murfreesboro for Cheyenne in 2003 were each dangerous and likely proved lethal after they built up in her system over time.
Walker pointed to the high amounts of one of the drugs’ byproducts found in the bloodstream of Cheyenne at the time of her death, noting it was at toxic levels .
‘That is enough toxicity to kill you or me,’ Walker told jurors, noting even a much smaller quantity would kill a 33-pound child like Cheyenne.
Walker said the three psychiatric drugs prescribed by Dr. Mudumbi each had a potential to be lethal but were especially dangerous when used together.
‘You have three drugs here which are killers,’ Walker testified. ‘It is an unpardonable sin to use three such drugs together.’
Walker explained the buildup of the drugs in the system, combined with something as simple as giving the child Pepto-Bismol (which she was given the day of her death for an upset stomach), could have had devastating effects. Walker said the Pepto may have sapped proteins (low in Cheyenne’s system) and allowed the psychiatric drugs free rein in the child’s system.
The result could be sudden arrhythmia of the heart, which led to cardiac arrest. At minimum, Walker said, a regular EKG of the child’s heart should have been made by the prescribing physician. Dr. Mudumbi ordered just one such EKG in 2003.
‘Where we failed this little child is she should have been monitored,’ Walker told jurors.
While Walker is convinced Cheyenne died as result of the drugs she was taking, special prosecutor Brian Holmgren pointed out she had been on the drugs for over a year with no reported side effects.
Along with Walker, Cheyenne’s attending pediatrician, Dr. Clifford Seyler, also maintained the child died from a drug reaction.
‘She had a history of a deranged child,’ Seyler testified of Cheyenne’s mental history given to him by Mathis. Seyler said that mental history prompted him to send Cheyenne to Dr. Mudumbi. ‘The bruises I saw on her I would say were the product of her mania.’
Seyler said he did not believe Cheyenne was strangled based on his review of the autopsy report.
‘I think she died due to toxic reactions to the medicines she was on,’ Seyler said, saying he felt Levy did not give enough credit to toxicology. ‘They basically ignored the lab work.’
Seyler went on to suggest the girl was suffering from a disease which may have interfered with her properly metabolizing the drugs and caused other side effects such as her alleged chronic itching. However, Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley refused to allow the testimony since the prosecution had no advance notice. Seyler said he discovered the possible disease just two days before he testified.
While saying he believed the child died to drug interaction, Dr. Seyler admitted on cross examination he had never seen any injuries, such as those shown on the autopsy photos, on the child during her 17 visits to his office. However, Seyler also maintained some of the photographs tended to highlight the bruises more than others.
Closing arguments begin Monday morning. The case will then go to the jury.

