Mathis says she had no motive for murder-She’s frantic during 911 call
|
‘She’s not breathing,’ Mathis exclaimed to the 911 operator during a panicked call for an ambulance, with the sounds of Mathis administering mouth-to-mouth to the child heard in the background as the operator told her help was on the way.
The frantic attempts for resuscitation and the concern in Mathis’ voice during the 911 call, the defense noted, are not behaviors of a person who had just strangled a child to death as claimed by prosecutors. Nor, the defense noted, are they consistent with claims by Cheyenne’s brothers that Mathis had choked all three of them during fits of anger.
‘I think they’ve been coached,’ asserted Mathis concerning earlier testimony by Cheyenne’s brothers, Ryan and David, that Mathis choked and beat them after she took legal custody of them beginning in 2001. ‘I’d assume by their parents.’
Mathis took the stand in her own behalf Thursday afternoon, denying accusations she strangled Cheyenne on June 26, 2004 at the Mathis home where Cheyenne and her older brothers had lived for three years. The children were in the custody of the former Small Wonders daycare owner because their biological parents were in trouble with the law due to drug problems.
‘I thought I would help them out,’ Mathis testified, saying she sought and obtained legal custody of the children in 2001 with the blessing of their parents Roxanne Haga and William Delp. ‘They (the parents) both agreed it would be best if they were kept in my home.’
After being awarded custody by Juvenile Court Judge Larry Ross, Mathis said she was directed by the court to have the children assessed by a psychologist, where, in turn, she was directed to take Cheyenne to a psychiatrist. Cheyenne would later be prescribed multiple medications for psychiatric disorders, medications which the defense has suggested were dangerous and may have caused the child to die from cardiac arrest.
Mathis downplayed allegations she was constantly seeking out new doctors for the children, saying the initial assessments were court ordered. The prosecution suggested Mathis would change doctors and also changed schools and classes for Cheyenne when allegations of abuse were made against Mathis. There were four Department of Children’s Services investigations for injuries found on Cheyenne’s body, all four of which ended without any charges or additional actions.
During her testimony, Mathis said she was at constant war with DCS once she won custody of the children, noting DCS refused to help her get insurance for them. Mathis pointed out she got less than $500 from Social Security, resisting prosecution claims she was trying to bilk the government for money by taking in the children.
‘I was told by DCS, ‘You won in court and now they’re your problem.’ Those were their exact words,’ Mathis said of her cold relationship with DCS. ‘They told me I was on my own.’
Mathis noted she had no plans to adopt the children but instead planned to keep them until their parents got their lives in order and could take them back.
‘I was praying their parents would realize how special their children were and get them back,’ said Mathis, resisting prosecution claims she was trying to turn the children against their parents by speaking about their legal problems in front of them. ‘I told their mother (Haga) that they needed a mother who is there all the time, not just when it is convenient for her.’
Taken back to the day of Cheyenne’s death, Mathis reiterated the story that the girl seemed ill that day and had thrown up before suddenly collapsing. Mathis admitted she had whipped the girl for drinking out of the dog’s bowl earlier.
‘I didn’t whip her hard,’ Mathis testified, denying she left the marks on the child’s body which were seen on pictures from Cheyenne’s autopsy.
While saying Cheyenne had more injuries generally than most people due to her excitable behavior, Mathis said she had not observed many of the injuries shown in the autopsy photos. She had given the girl a bath earlier on the day of her mysterious death.
Given her inability to explain many of the bruises, special prosecutor Brian Holmgren suggested Mathis had a selective memory and had changed stories over the four years since Cheyenne’s death.
‘We aren’t going to have a Perry Mason moment where you break down and confess, are we’? Holmgren asked in cross-examining Mathis, suggesting jurors should not expect Mathis to act shaken when pushed by prosecutors about her story.
The defense is expected to conclude today following the testimony of medical experts. The jury is expected to get the case for deliberation Monday.

