Skip to content

Mathis family saw no abuse

Mathis family saw no abuse

Robert Mathis testified yesterday the Delp children often lied.
The husband and children of accused murderess Sherri Mathis testified Thursday their home was a pleasant one ‘ dispelling earlier testimony by the brothers of Cheyenne Delp that it was a house of horrors, filled with beatings and cruelty.

‘We were all treated the same,’ testified Mathis’ 12-year-old daughter, Brianna, of how her siblings and Cheyenne’s siblings, who were in Mathis’ legal custody and lived in the family home, were treated.

Brianna testified she was spanked and that she also knew of Cheyenne and her brothers, Ryan and David being spanked by Mathis on various occasions. However, she said the spankings were never severe and that her mother never choked anyone.

‘She never whooped us hard,’ Brianna testified, recalling she had seen Cheyenne scratch herself, bolstering defense claims many of the bruises found on the child’s body at her death were self-inflicted.

Brianna’s older sister, Tiffany, 16, supported Brianna’s testimony saying that spankings were done with a belt but that her mother would never choke anyone. Both Brianna and Tiffany agreed Cheyenne would have hallucinations where she saw tigers and snakes, backing up defense claims the child suffered from serious mental illness.

The oldest of the Mathis children, Josh, now 21, also said he never knew of his mother abusing or choking anyone. He told the court Cheyenne and her brothers were known to lie.

‘Ryan and David weren’t real truthful,’ Josh testified, noting he feels his mother has been falsely accused.

Mathis’ husband of 21 years and the father of Josh, Brianna and Tiffany, agreed with his oldest son, saying the Delp children were less than truthful.

‘They would tell lies on one another,’ testified Robert Mathis, noting the children appeared to be happy when he saw them, although he knew Cheyenne suffered from some mental issues.

Mr. Mathis pointed out it was his wife’s decision to take custody of the Delp children, adding he was away at work a lot and often would not get home until in the evening.

‘We weren’t planning to keep them forever,’ Mr. Mathis said. ‘Just until their parents could take them back.’

The Mathis family was unified on saying Cheyenne would inflict injuries on herself either by her hyperactivity or by constantly picking and scratching at herself.

Their observations were backed up by special education teacher Christy Hickerson, who said she saw several issues with the child when she was in her class up until early 2004. Her assistant teacher, Mary Lou Hunter, agreed, saying they would see marks on the child a lot, marks they believed were caused by her constant scratching.

Leave a Comment