Skip to content

Stanley denies Mathis mistrial

Defense attorney Jack Lowery made a motion for a mistrial in the Sherri Mathis murder case Monday morning, claiming assistant prosecutor Kristen Menke had a ‘courtroom breakdown’ in the presence of the jury while introducing pictures of victim Cheyenne Delp into evidence.

However, Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley denied the motion, and added he didn’t interpret a brief pause by Menke to constitute a ‘breakdown.’

The incident took place Friday afternoon when Menke was about to enter into evidence pictures of the badly bruised body of 6-year-old Cheyenne. The pictures were taken at River Park Hospital after medical personnel were unable to save her life.

‘The introduction of pictures was so prejudicial in their nature, there’s a high likelihood the jury is not going to consider any more evidence from the state, or from us, due to the impact of those pictures,’ said Lowery. ‘We don’t think she can now get a fair trial.’

Prosecutor Brian Holmgren countered by saying the photos illustrate the physical condition of the child, and admitted the pictures are disturbing.

‘This is a horrific case. There’s no getting around that,’ said Holmgren. ‘The jury should see the nature of the conduct Mrs. Mathis is accused of.’

Judge Stanley had ruled previously to allow the pictures to be entered into evidence and he said nothing in Menke’s presentation would alter his previous decision. Stanley also said it’s not realistic to have the medical examiner point to a diagram of the human body and tell jurors where bruises were found, as the defense suggested.

‘Due to the nature of the injuries, a description of the injuries would be almost impossible to do with a diagram,’ said Stanley. ‘I think any prejudice is outweighed by the ability of the pictures to show the nature of the injuries.’

After Stanley denied the motion for a mistrial, jurors were allowed to enter the courtroom and the prosecution continued its case.

Leave a Comment