Skip to content

‘I didn’t see any tears’-Doctor says Mathis not emotional upon hearing of Cheyenne’s death

There were no tears of sorrow in the eyes of accused murderess Sherri Mathis when informed 6-year-old Cheyenne Delp was dead, according to the doctor who tried to save the girl’s life at River Park Hospital.

Dr. James Parker testified Monday he was surprised by such a reaction.

‘I was kind of struck by that,’ testified River Park emergency room doctor James Parker. ‘She immediately started telling me how the child would hurt herself and self-mutilate herself before I ever mentioned the injuries. Most people are sorrowful for losing a child. She seemed fearful. I didn’t see any tears.’

Dr. Parker said that multiple marks he found on the child’s body were indicative of battered child syndrome.

Parker said he was never able to get vital signs on the child after the girl collapsed mysteriously at the Mathis home where she and her two brothers, Ryan and David, had lived as wards of the state for three years. Both Ryan and David have testified Mathis beat and choked both of them and their sister.

They testified Mathis whipped their sister twice the day of her death.

During his testimony, Dr. Parker said Mathis’ unusual reaction to being told of the death of the child was only one of the things which set off alarm bells the day of Cheyenne’s death.

‘She (Mathis) told me the girl started choking on a cracker and that she placed her in the bathtub,’ recalled Parker, saying the girl’s clothes and body were wet. Parker added he could not understand why Mathis would have put the child in a bathtub as a way to revive the girl. ‘I didn’t find any obstruction in her windpipe, although there was some water noted.’

Along with the questionable explanation about placing the choking child in a bathtub, Dr. Parker said he noted multiple bruises, of various ages, all over the child’s body, ranging from buttocks, legs and belly to the throat, back and mouth. Photographs of the bruised child were shown to jurors ‘ the photos graphic enough where some family members of the deceased child left before they were displayed on an overhead projector.

After viewing the pictures, Parker said such a pattern of bruising would be consistent with battered child syndrome, noting he felt trauma could have been a reason for the death, disputing the defense claim that high doses of psychiatric drugs caused her sudden death. He did, however, say such psychiatric drugs, in large doses, have been known in other cases to lead to sudden death.

The unusual behavior cited by Dr. Parker was backed by McMinnville policeman Steve Cohler, who said Mathis immediately burst into explaining how self-mutilating Cheyenne was even before being asked about the injuries at the hospital.

‘Right off the bat she mentioned the child was crazy,’ Cohler recalled, saying in his original report Mathis used the word ‘crazy’ to describe the child.

Leave a Comment