Skip to content

Child battered over long span, Levy says

Child battered over long span, Levy says

MATHIS
With jurors looking at gruesome pictures of 6-year-old Cheyenne Delp’s back criss-crossed with strap marks, forensic pathologist Bruce Levy testified Tuesday the marks demonstrated a pattern of abuse perpetrated by accused murderess Sherri Mathis which culminated when the former daycare owner allegedly strangled the 33-pound child in her home.

‘The only conclusion you can draw is that Cheyenne was battered over a long period of time,’ Dr. Levy told jurors pointing to both old and fresh marks located all over Cheyenne’s body and photographed during her autopsy. ‘There is no other explanation for the injuries.’

Dr. Levy declared Delp’s death a homicide after conducting an autopsy and investigation following the child’s mysterious death in the Mathis home where she and her brothers had been wards of the state for three years. Levy said Cheyenne died from asphyxia from strangulation complicated by battered child syndrome.

In basing his opinion, Levy pointed to wounds on the neck, appearing to be finger marks, which were located at points Levy believes Mathis clutched the child’s neck for the alleged fatal choking incident. Along with the surface marks, Levy said an autopsy revealed the injuries were even in the muscle tissue beneath the skin, suggesting an extreme amount of force had been used.

Levy resisted suggestions by defense attorney Michael Galligan that Cheyenne had inflicted the injuries on herself as part of self-mutilating behavior brought on by the child’s alleged mental problems.

Levy said the injuries to normally inaccessible areas of the body like the lower back are unlikely places for a person to inflict self-harm, noting there were apparent patterns to the belt marks on the girl’s back but no scarring to the neck, which would have been left if, as alleged by Mathis, the girl had compulsively pawed at her neck.

‘The injuries appeared to have been caused by a human hand,’ Levy said of the marks on the child’s throat, noting it could take as little as 30 seconds for a person to lose consciousness while being choked, and then another two to four minutes to suffer irreversible brain damage.

As for the chance Cheyenne died from over-ingesting her psychiatrist-prescribed medications for her alleged mental illnesses, Dr. Levy said while the medicines are potent and have been known to be fatal, the mode of her death is clear in his opinion.

‘If I had not known for sure I could have put cause of death undetermined,’ Dr. Levy said. ‘But in this case, the cause of death is known.’

Testimony will resume today at 9 a.m. as Dr. Levy concluded his portion of testimony late Tuesday afternoon.

Leave a Comment