Skip to content

Watch out for 5-star funds

Mutual funds have proven once again they are unable to sustain their track records — thwarting the simplistic efforts and inaccurate expectations of neophyte investors. If you ever want to test an investor’s knowledge about mutual funds, just ask him or her if Morningstar ratings are important. The more important the investor says they are, the less the investor knows about mutual funds. Every study ever conducted — including those published by Morningstar itself — shows that fund ratings have no predictive quality.

You’re as likely to make lots of money by investing in 1-star funds as you are by investing in 5-star funds. That’s because the ratings simply reflect past performance. They do not attempt to predict how funds will perform in the future. Experienced investors know this, and that’s why they disregard fund ratings.

But neophytes think ratings matter. You can’t blame them, really. After all, ratings are common. Cars, consumer electronics, even movies get ratings. Consumers have learned that ratings are reliable — everyone agrees that a 5-star movie is worth seeing and that 1-star refrigerators aren’t worth buying. Why, then, can’t you rely on fund ratings? The answer is simple.

Products are identical and can be expected to produce the same results every time. For example, use a toaster 10 times the same way and you’ll get the same results every time. But on the 11th try, while the toaster is on, turn the knob to the next-higher number. Think your results will be the same as before?

This explains why mutual funds can’t replicate their past performance: Their environment is constantly changing. If next year’s economic environment is different from last year’s — and it will be — you can’t expect a given investment to perform next year like it did last year. Every year is different from the last, with changes in interest rates, inflation, corporate profits, employment levels, political and social issues, etc.

Here is the most recent industry research proving my point: Standard & Poor’s has recently measured the performance of mutual funds for the five years ending June 30, 2006. Of the funds that were ranked in the top half of all mutual funds, only 9 percent were still in the top-half ranking five years later. Only 1 percent maintained their top-quartile ranking.

And here are some extreme examples from Standard & Poor’s research: One fund, which in 2001 was among the top 1 percent of all mutual funds, fell to the bottom 100th percentile in 2005. Another, which was in the top 1 percent of all funds in 2003 and 2004, was in the 100th percentile in 2005. (Yep, it literally went from best to worst in a single year!) These examples demonstrate the dangers of choosing investments based solely on past performance. This is why you must never, but never, pay any attention to mutual fund ratings.

Financial Adviser Ric Edelman can be reached by e-mail at [email protected].

Leave a Comment