Skip to content

Pill needed to cure healthcare ills

Americans have lost confidence in the U.S. healthcare system and yearn for reforms that will free them from worry about losing coverage if their circumstances change or if they fall ill.

In a recent Consumer Reports survey, more than 80 percent of the 1,200 Americans age 18 and older polled said that a reformed system should guarantee the following:

‘ Coverage for all uninsured children.

‘ Protection against financial ruin due to an illness or accident.

‘ The ability to obtain coverage regardless of a pre-existing condition.

‘ Coverage that continues even when people are laid off, changing jobs or starting their own business.

‘ Premiums, deductibles and out-of-pocket expenses that are affordable relative to family income.

Right now, pessimism about U.S. healthcare costs prevails among consumers regardless of age, gender, political orientation or family income. Overall, 81 percent of those CR polled said they are concerned about being able to afford health care in retirement, 68 percent worry about being bankrupted by medical bills following a serious illness or accident, and 65 percent fear losing their job-related health coverage. Respondents laid the blame for America’s healthcare problems mainly on drug and insurance companies.

REFORM: SWEATING

THE DETAILS

When asked about how, exactly, a reformed health system would work, respondents were considerably more divided than they were about what such a system should achieve. CR asked consumers for their opinions on four approaches to reform, including those proposed by leading presidential candidates.

The most popular proposal drew support from half of the respondents. That was for a mixed public/private system that would require all uninsured Americans to buy health insurance. The cost of the insurance, deductibles and co-pays would be adjusted based on income, with subsidies for lower-income Americans. Massachusetts is in the midst of implementing that type of system, and the leading Democratic candidates have proposed versions of it.

Thirty-six percent of poll respondents support public insurance, which would move all Americans, including those now covered through private insurance, to a Medicare-like plan funded by federal taxes. This approach is similar to Canada’s healthcare system.

One-third of respondents CR surveyed favored a mix of employer-sponsored plans, private health-insurance plans, Medicare, Medicaid and other public programs, the arrangement Americans have today. Only 26 percent supported the idea of giving tax incentives for individuals to purchase insurance and relying on market pressures and competition among insurance companies to hold prices down.

Interestingly, even respondents who identified themselves as conservatives picked a mixed public/private systems as their top choice, and one-third favored an all-public plan.

GETTING IT DONE

Healthcare reform will be a central issue in this year’s presidential election. Consumers Union, the nonprofit publisher of Consumer Reports, will press for changes that ensure that all Americans can get high-quality health care at a price they can afford.

Consumers Union will use the following criteria to judge state and federal proposals that come up for debate:

‘ Complete coverage. Private insurance and public programs, such as Medicare, Medicaid and the State Children’s Health Insurance Program, must be expanded to guarantee that everyone is covered from cradle to grave, regardless of health status and ability to pay.

‘ Fair cost spreading. No family should face financial ruin to pay for health care. Costs should be spread fairly among government, employers and consumers.

‘ Safer care. Millions of Americans are harmed each year by the care they receive. Improved safety systems would save billions of health-system dollars.

‘ Prevention. Smoking- and obesity-related illnesses such as certain cancers, heart disease and diabetes threaten to overwhelm health expenditures. Reforms should give patients and doctors more support for banishing bad habits before they lead to costly illnesses.

Leave a Comment