Opposing Viewpoints-Online business does no harm
McMinnville Mayor Royce Davenport had the perfect solution when asked about an adult-oriented store that located within the city limits called Hanky Pankys. The mayor said if people are truly offended by the store, then they shouldn’t shop there and the problem would take care of itself.
Sure enough, Hanky Pankys shut its doors in about a month ‘ and with minimal controversy. City leaders didn’t have to rely on government regulations for the Hanky Pankys situation to resolve itself.
Now it’s county government that’s wrestling with a vaguely similar situation with the discovery of an online adult-oriented business called Pleasures Down South. In direct contrast to the city, county officials are threatening to force this Web site to shut down.
There are times when government goes too far and oversteps its boundaries. This is one of those times.
It should be fully noted Pleasures Down South has no retail location. There are no signs, no flashing lights, outside the home where the Web site is operated. Outside of the street address and P.O. box listed on the business license, there is no way to know this business operates in Warren County.
When government regulates any type of product ‘ whether it’s alcohol, tobacco or adult-oriented material ‘ two basic factors must be considered.
The first is whether the product can be harmful. The second is whether the product can be offensive.
In response to the first question, I don’t see any harm in a Web site that offers products for consenting adults. We elect our county officials to serve this community, not police our bedrooms.
In answer to the second, I can easily see how a store broadcasting adult-oriented merchandise could be offensive. But I see no problem with someone operating such a business on the Internet.
If less government is the best government, this is a case where the county should stay on the sidelines.
