Trouble brewing for Democrats
Democrats could face two troubling issues at their convention next summer. By what standard should superdelegates cast their ballots? And should Florida and Michigan — now benched for violating party rules — have a vote after all?
Party leaders never confronted these questions because they assumed the nominations would be settled long before they meet in Denver on Aug. 25. (That includes Hillary Clinton, who was practically broke after Super Tuesday.) And the primaries could still produce a decisive outcome.
Barack Obama’s sweep in the “Potomac primary” gives him a sizable lead, and if Clinton loses Ohio and Texas on March 4 she can’t catch him. But it’s possible that the primaries will end in June without a clear victor, and at that point, the delegate count would become critical.
There are 796 superdelegates out of 4,049 (not counting Florida and Michigan), or about 20 percent of the total. Most are party leaders, elected officials, big donors — Clinton and Obama, as sitting senators, are both superdelegates — and they are free to support any candidate, no matter how the popular vote in their state turns out.
Obama expects to win more states and more votes than Clinton, so he is insisting that the superdelegates should follow the returns. His argument obviously reflects his self-interest, but it has a lot of validity.
“My strong belief,” Obama said recently, “is that if we end up with the most states and the most pledged delegates, and the most voters in the country, then it would be problematic for political insiders to overturn the judgment of the voters.”
The spectacle of party operatives rejecting a popular choice could rip the Democrats apart and diminish their chances in November. The pain grows if mainly white superdelegates pass over a black candidate.
This dispute reflects one of the oldest arguments in political theory: Should elected representatives merely follow “the judgment of the voters,” or should they “exercise independent judgment” based on their own values and experience?
The classic statement on this matter remains the one made in 1774 by the British philosopher Edmund Burke, in his famous speech to the electors of Bristol. The views of the voters, he said, “ought to have great weight” with any elected official, “and above all, ever, and in all cases (he should) prefer their interest to his own.”
However, Burke added, any official must also listen to his “enlightened conscience.” Therefore, “your representative owes you, not his industry only, but his judgment; and he betrays, instead of serving you, if he sacrifices it to your opinion.”
The second question concerns Florida and Michigan, which were penalized for holding their primaries earlier than party rules dictated. These two large states account for 366 delegates, 9 percent of the current total, and since Clinton won both primaries, she is vociferously arguing for those delegates to count. Team Obama cries foul, saying he didn’t contest the primaries and should not be punished for playing by the rules.
On this point we agree with Obama. Clinton did not win those delegates fairly and should not gain an advantage by having them seated.
But on the question of the superdelegates, Clinton has the better argument. If their role was simply to ratify the popular vote, why have them at all? If Ted Kennedy can exercise his “independent judgment” and defy the voters of Massachusetts, why can’t superdelegates in states like Illinois and Connecticut, which backed Obama, do exactly the same thing?
Burke got it right 234 years ago. In a democracy, representatives should give “great weight” to their constituents. But they should also consult their “enlightened conscience,” even when it goes against the popular will.
Steve and Cokie Roberts can be contacted by e-mail at [email protected].
