No more trial delays for Mathis
There will be no more continuances in the murder trial of former daycare owner Sherri Mathis as Judge Bart Stanley flatly denied a last-minute continuance motion by the defense yesterday and decreed the trial will begin at 9 a.m. Tuesday morning.
Mathis, 41, who is charged with first-degree murder for the 2004 strangulation death of her 6-year-old ward of the court, Cheyenne Delp, had asked the court to delay her case ‘ a delay which would have been the sixth continuance.
As grounds, the defense first maintained Mathis had recently undergone a medical procedure and would not be able to assist the defense team.
‘She is in no condition to assist in her defense,’ said defense attorney John Partin, saying his client is still suffering from the aftereffects of the procedure.
However, special prosecutor Brian Holmgren pointed out Mathis has had three years to assist in her defense given the delayed nature of the case, noting Mathis has consistently not been present during pre-trial hearings.
‘That just doesn’t cut the mustard,’ declared Holmgren, suggesting if Mathis truly wanted to be involved in her defense then she would at least come to court.
The second matter addressed in the hearing concerned the inability of one of the defense’s expert witnesses to appear due to health problems.
‘This expert is critical to our client’s defense,’ Partin told the court, noting the expert pathologist hired by the defense would refute the state’s theory the victim died due to strangulation and asphyxiation.
Holmgren disagreed, noting the defense has other experts who will testify and that the pathologist in question would try to explain away injuries on the child’s body without basing his opinion on scientifically accepted facts. Holmgren said the expert would blame the child’s death on toxicity caused by her medications and that he would try to say marks on the child’s body were caused by attempts to revive her using CPR.
‘Dr. Levy (the state pathologist) will say that CPR did not cause these injuries and that in all his years in pathology he has not seen such injuries caused by an attempt to revive a person,’ said Holmgren. ‘It took them two years just to find someone to support their theory.’
Holmgren went on to say the repeated delays have caused inconvenience for his office and for judges in his district who have had to put off cases there because he is special prosecutor here.
Upon completion of the arguments yesterday, Judge Stanley immediately told the attorneys the case will go to trial as scheduled Tuesday morning, overruling the defense’s request for a continuance.
