Mutual fund scandals are still common
The retail mutual-fund industry scandal surfaced in 2003. Is the scandal old news? Have the deceptive business practices vanished?
You might think so if you listen to people who claim the problems the scandal created are gone.
I wish that were so. Unfortunately, the retail mutual-fund industry continues to engage in misleading, unfair and deceptive business practices. As proof, consider recent news from the industry.
‘ Shareholders at 41 of the nation’s biggest mutual fund families are paying significantly higher fees than they did just five years ago, says a new study by SmartMoney magazine.
‘ Half of all mutual funds now employ waivers to trick investors into thinking fees are lower than they actually are, according to the mutual fund research firm Lipper, Inc.
The reasons fees are increasing are because these waivers are being lifted. Often, a mutual fund company waives a portion of its fee as a teaser to get a customer to invest. After a year or two, quietly and without fanfare, the company eliminates the waiver. The fees dramatically rise, but investors don’t notice, because fees are not shown on their statements.
‘ Fees covering portfolio-trading costs may be an even bigger drag on mutual fund performance than initially thought, according to a story in Investment News. Researchers from Virginia Tech, the University of Virginia and Boston College found that the average stock fund is spending 1.44 percent of its assets per year on trading costs. That’s in addition to the fund’s normal operating expenses, known as the annual expense ratio. (Morningstar says the average expense ratio is 1.5 percent per year.) But the trading costs are not revealed in the prospectus or on monthly statements ‘ and the more a fund trades, the higher that cost.
‘ A study by Harvard University and the Marshall School of Business at the University of Southern California found that mutual fund managers are showing a preference for companies that give them retirement-plan business. In other words, according to this study, some fund managers are selecting stocks to keep their corporate clients happy, not because they think the stocks are good for the people who buy their funds. This quid-pro-quo system is absolutely scandalous.
‘ Despite billions of dollars in fines, with dozens of people ousted from the industry and many in prison for their roles in illegal market-timing schemes, 70 percent of mutual fund executives surveyed by Artemis Strategy Group say they expect illegal market-timing to continue.
I could go on, but you get the point: The astonishing revelations of deceit, intentional confusion, and outright chicanery in the retail mutual fund industry are continuing. As a result investors are paying higher fees, taking greater risks and earning lower returns than they realize.
So, the mutual fund scandal is ‘gone’? Hardly! In fact, it continues unabated.
Financial Adviser Ric Edelman can be reached by e-mail at [email protected].
