Skip to content

I’d never plead guilty if innocent

I can be an outspoken person and I can also be an opinionated person. In some instances, the combination of the two wouldn’t work out very well. However, while having to write a column about my opinions, it helps to have those two.

Case in point, while watching TV with my husband the other night, there was an investigation show. During the show, a man was shot. His wife’s story changed three times. She initially claimed he shot himself. Then, she shot him and by the time they got to court, someone else shot him. Her attorney went to court and claimed police coercion to get the confession.

There were two separate interviews that lasted several hours each. During the interviews, the officers told the woman that her statement of what happened, he shot himself, didn’t match the evidence. If they were going to help her, she had to tell them the truth ‘ a typical police ploy. She eventually confessed.

The case: When she called the police after the shooting, she claimed he shot himself and then stumbled into the room to her. However, people who shoot themselves usually don’t hide the weapon. In this case the weapon was never found.

Reconstructing the chain of events, by the statement of neighbors who heard the shot and the time when she called the police, they proved several minutes passed between the shots fired and her call to the police. By her own account, she did not offer first aid. So, what was she doing?

During this time, at least one neighbor witnessed her crossing the street to the trash cans and coming back to the apartment building. Emptied early the morning of the shooting, officers didn’t find the gun and weren’t able to prove that is where the gun was thrown.

This is when the story changed to a confession and she was charged with murder. For court, her story then changed a third time. Now, he was shot through the window by someone outside the apartment, hence the broken window.

There is only one version of the truth. If it is the truth, the version never changes. Innocent people do not say they are guilty no matter what the police tell them or how long they are questioned. However, I do believe teenagers, young children and the mentally incompetent could be persuaded to say they are guilty when they aren’t.

The discussion between us led to a question of plea agreements. Should an innocent person plead guilty in order to get a light sentence when they are faced with an extended prison sentence?

Innocent people should not plead guilty and if they do, they shouldn’t. Although some view plea agreements as get-out-of-jail free cards, they aren’t.

Plea agreements do mean you’ll get out of jail sooner when compared to being found guilty. However, the downside is you are now guilty. Also, in most instances, the record you willingly accepted will follow you no matter how loud you proclaim your innocence.

For those who accept plea agreements when innocent, there will never be innocence. With a plea agreement, innocence is surrendered.

I would never plead guilty to something I did not do, regardless of the time threatened. If I’m found guilty and go to jail, knowing I’m innocent will have to get me through while I fight to prove it.

My husband doesn’t agree. He thinks, given the right circumstances and facing considerable jail time, I would take a plea to walk out of jail and come home.

In the end, we agreed to disagree.

Lisa Hobbs is a reporter for the Standard. She can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].

Leave a Comment