Skip to content

National primary day badly needed

While it may make them feel all important and fuzzy during primary time with candidates tripping over themselves to shake their hands and kiss their babies, the whole practice of having states like Iowa and New Hampshire basically determine the front-runners before the other 99 percent of America gets a crack at them is ridiculous.

Yesterday, 24 states including Tennessee held their primaries in what is called Super Tuesday, a day which decides a major portion of the total delegates who will elect the Republican and Democrat nominees for President of the United States. However, by the time these people had their say, a large field of the original candidates were either already forced to leave the race due to poor showings in little states like Iowa, New Hampshire and South Carolina, or, even worse, they were corrupted and seen as ‘out of it’ by voters who didn’t want to waste their vote.

‘I’d vote for him but he’s so far behind I don’t want to waste my vote,’ I’ve heard many voters say when it came to candidates like John Edwards and Mike Huckabee, labeled as also-rans after poor showings in some of the little states.

It fascinates me why the major parties allow states like Iowa and New Hampshire to basically soil the electoral process. It’d be like going ahead here and announcing the results of early voting before balloters took to the polls. What would happen if we did that before a local election? If a candidate was ahead by 20 percent for county executive, what would happen? Well, first off voters likely wouldn’t vote for the person trailing and second, if there were no other races, they might not bother showing up at the polls at all.

It’s doubly worse in presidential primaries because it costs so much to run a campaign, especially when you waste millions in Iowa and New Hampshire alone. The big money is being bet on the front-runners because contributors want a return on their investment and if the small, early states aren’t looking good, contributors pull the plug and invest in the flavor of the week.

That’s what got the Democrats John Kerry last time. That’s also what got them Dukakis and Mondale as the candidates did well in the early states but weren’t worth a flip when put in the national spotlight.

What needs to happen is a national primary day where all 50 states vote at once. If that means candidates spend more money in California, New York, and Florida, then so be it. At least then the voters will have a full field to choose from instead of having to pick from New Hampshire’s leftovers.

And, for goodness sake, lets pick a day in March or April as the primaries keep sneaking forward to where pretty soon the new president will have to start buying ad space for the next election during his inauguration address.

While tradition is well and good, I think both parties are doing their followers a great injustice by the present system. And, as shown by discipline heaped upon Michigan and Florida for sliding their primaries forward, the major parties can force the individual states in line and perhaps even come to an agreement where Republican and Democrats vote in all 50 states on the same day.

The parties owe it to us to give us a level playing field instead of having us select from a menu of warmed-over candidates hand-picked for us by 1 percent of the electorate.

Duane Sherrill is a reporter for the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].

Leave a Comment