Skip to content

Sister turns in brother for bank robbery-Unknowingly, she was driving getaway car

A man who botched a drive-thru bank robbery has now been charged with the heist of another bank weeks earlier ‘ and he was fingered for the crime by his own sister.

The suspect, Carl Anthony Brakeall Jr., 34, of Harrison Ferry Mountain has been indicted on the charge of aggravated robbery for the Oct. 4 armed heist of Citizens Tri-County Bank in Plaza Shopping Center.

That indictment joins an indictment for attempted robbery for his ill-conceived attempted heist of the Citizens Tri-County branch in Mt. Leo.

Brakeall, who has been held under a $500,000 bond since his arrest Oct. 26, hours after the attempted Mt. Leo robbery, is the masked man police now say entered the Plaza branch Oct. 4 wielding a handgun.

In that robbery, police say he fled the scene on foot after taking an undisclosed amount of money from a bank teller. Investigators say Brakeall ran from the bank to his sister’s car which was parked nearby. The sister reportedly claimed she was not in on a conspiracy to rob the bank and did not realize her brother had committed the heist until he jumped in the car and told her to drive away.

Brakeall was considered as a potential suspect in the Plaza heist after he was arrested for the attempted Mt. Leo heist, which occurred 22 days later.

In the case of the Mt. Leo crime, police say Brakeall allegedly pulled up to the drive-thru window at Citizens Tri-County Bank, located on Beersheba Street near its intersection with Highway 8, on a motorcycle. The teller said the bandit, who was wearing a bandana partially over his face just as was the case in the Plaza heist, passed her a note through the deposit tube warning her he had rigged the bank to explode and that he would detonate the explosives if she did not hand over the bank’s money. He also lifted his shirt to reveal a firearm.

At that point the teller, who was behind bullet-resistant glass, retreated to another room of the small branch at which time she heard the cyclist speed off in the direction of Harrison Ferry, prompting her call to police.

When police arrived, they discovered the bandit was likely someone who had done business with the bank before as he was reportedly recognized during his short stay at the window. Another tip received by police led them to Brakeall’s home atop the mountain, where they found items such as the blue motorcycle helmet worn in the attempted heist.

It was during subsequent questioning that Brakeall allegedly admitted involvement in the attempted heist, claiming it was all a joke and that he became scared and fled when he saw the teller run away.

Police doubt the Mt. Leo incident was ever intended as a joke given the advance preparation of the note and his carrying a firearm, which lawmen learned was actually a BB gun. It is unknown if he was also carrying a BB gun in the Plaza heist.

Leave a Comment