Skip to content

Thumbs-up & Thumbs-down-Recognizing the great (and not-so-great) sports items of ’07

Thumbs-up & Thumbs-down-Recognizing the great (and not-so-great) sports items of '07
Another busy sports year is nearing its conclusion, and media organizations around the country are bestowing awards for story of the year, athlete of the year and the like.

The Southern Standard sports department prefers to set trends, rather than follow them, but in this case, we’ll make an exception and dole out a few awards of our own. But as we look back on 2007, we’d prefer to not single out any particular people or incidents. Instead, we’ll just give a few approving ‘thumbs-ups,’ or in some cases a ‘thumbs-down,’ to some of the highlights and lowlights of the past 12 months.

Thumbs-up: To the new gymnasium at Centertown Elementary. The new school, as a whole, is a showplace and hopefully a model for others to look to when the need for more new buildings arises. But for sports fans, the gym is truly a palace ‘ especially whe0n you have to, as many of us do, squeeze your way into some of the more tiny arenas around the county.

Having a nice, big playing floor and plenty of seats may not seem like a big deal to other communities, but if you’ve ever tried to work your way down the sideline at Morrison or Irving College, you’ll know why going to a game in the Warriors’ new home is a treat.

Thumbs-down: To playing basketball during baseball season.

We know everyone is trying to get better, and the more you can practice, presumably, the better your team will be. But putting together an elementary basketball tournament in May is taking things a little past the extreme.

They’re kids, after all. Let them play little league, and save the indoor games for cold weather.

Thumbs-up: To Pioneer golfer Brett Patterson, for making his mark as one of the state’s top players even though only a sophomore.

We don’t want to put any undue pressure on you, Brett, but Dale really likes going to the state golf tournament each fall. He’d appreciate a couple more trips. But next time, see if you can bring the rest of your team with you.

Thumbs-down: To the WCHS boys’ soccer team, for falling in first round of the District 7-AAA tournament in a 3-2 upset to Lebanon. The season had a lot of promise, and the Blue Devils hadn’t posed much of problem in their earlier game. But alas, a region trip wasn’t meant to be after a first-round meltdown.

Thumbs-up: To the Pioneer football team, for showing up and playing hard against Riverdale in the first round of the 2007 playoffs. You earned the respect of everyone in the stadium, including Warrior fans who know a thing or two about winning football programs. An added thumb-up for electing not to jump on the midfield logo this year.

Thumbs-down: To sports editor Rob Nunley for predicting the Pioneers would lose their playoff game by 42 points. But maybe that was just a ploy to try and make sure the guys would play hard. Sure, that’s it… that’s the ticket.

Thumbs-down: To putting Ensworth on the football schedule. We know there are friendships involved and everything, and we’re firmly convinced the Pioneer program is on the upswing. But are they ready to compete with private schools?

On the other hand, Tim McGraw showed up for the game. So maybe we’ll call this one a ‘thumbs-sideways.’

Thumbs-up: Two thumbs, in fact, to the TSSAA’s new ‘mercy’ rule. Let’s face it: When you’re down 35 points, you’re beat. So there’s no sense in delaying the inevitable. And that 30-minute second half at Crossville was greeted with open arms by Pioneer fans and Jet fans alike. Finally, a rule that makes sense.

Thumbs-up: To Vanderbilt football coach Bobby Johnson for making the Commodore football program respectable again.

Thumbs-down: Bobby Johnson for not taking a better coaching job. Loyalty is one thing, but this is still Vandy we’re talking about. Get out while the getting’s good, coach.

Thumbs-down: To Barry Bonds for putting a black eye on the home run record. The most respected, most well-known record in the history of pro sports is tainted, no matter what Bonds says. Here’s hoping A-Rod hits 800.

Thumbs-up: To Hank Aaron for being stand-up guy enough to deliver a video of congratulations, and for giving fans someone worthwhile to cheer on that historic* night when Bonds hit the record-breaker*.

Thumbs-up: To the New England Patriots for making moves during the offseason to make an already talented team even better.

Thumbs-down: For resorting to rule-breaking, even with all of that talent. Perfect season or not, Super Bowl championship or not, ‘Spy-gate’ will linger on and cast an ugly shadow on the Pats’ success.

Thumbs-up: To Albert Haynesworth, for not getting in any trouble (so far) and helping the Titans’ defense become one of the league’s best. You could see the ex-Vol’s impact on the program when he had to miss a few games which ‘ for once ‘ weren’t the result of a league suspension.

Thumbs-down: To anybody who gets upset because we either mentioned them, or left them out, of this piece. Only half of these are serious, after all. And no, we’re not telling you which half.

Thumbs-up: To everyone who helped us do our jobs, and enjoy them, once again this year. Our best wishes for a healthy and happy 2008 to you all.

Leave a Comment