City tobacco ban passes final reading
Tighter restrictions on tobacco-using city employees passed final reading Dec. 18 at the regular meeting of McMinnville Board of Mayor and Aldermen. The decision lacked the support of one elected official who voted against the ordinance after being asked to by city employees.
‘People asked me to vote no for them,’ said Alderman Rick Barnes. ‘According to the current ordinance, unless they are on break they can’t chew or smoke. Even if they are out by themselves or operating a shovel in a ditch.’
The changes to the employee policy does not allow employees to use any tobacco product while on duty unless they are on break. Included in this ban is the use of tobacco products in city buildings, vehicles or in city equipment, or while using city equipment.
‘If it’s one o’clock in the morning and a city policeman is on patrol and he wants to smoke, he has to stop his car and get outside and smoke,’ said Barnes. The absurdity of the situation prompted him to add, ‘Maybe we should outlaw the sale of tobacco in the city limits and that would solve all their problems. There you go.’
On Nov. 13, members of the Finance Committee began discussing changing the no-smoking ban to include smokeless tobacco. Also discussed was increasing the distance employees must be from city building entrances from 10 feet to 50.
The discussion came after complaints were received by employees and the public. While cigarette-using employees complained that they were being singled out because smokeless users were allowed to use at will, calls were received from city residents who didn’t like seeing employees using tobacco products while at work.
At that time, members expressed the same concerns voiced by Barnes, as well as their hesitancy to increase the distance by 40 feet. It was decided to postpone the vote in order to consider it further before making a decision.
At Tuesday night’s committee meeting, the measure was once again discussed. The policy distance was changed to 20 feet and no concerns were raised. However, the tobacco restrictions remained and the same concerns discussed.
‘If you’ve got some water department guy down here at a pump station that is nowhere near the public and he has a city shovel in his hand, then that is city equipment and he is prohibited,’ said Alderman Patti Nunley, who believes employees out of the public eye and outside should not be restricted.
That same sentiment was expressed by aldermen Bobby Kirby and Billy Wood and both added that they believed a lone employee should be allowed to smoke in a vehicle.
Despite the officials’ hesitancy, department directors were all for restricting tobacco use no matter where the employee may be at the time or what they are doing.
‘I have a lot of employees who are in vehicles by themselves all day long,’ said Public Works director Bill Brock. ‘They smoke in the vehicle all day long. The day they are on vacation or the day they are sick and I put a nonsmoker in that vehicle I get complaints.’
The discussion to allow tobacco use if an employee is out of the public eye brought this response by McMinnville Police Chief Charlie Sewell, ‘How do you narrow it to this one who is over in the woods but not a police officer who is standing in the middle of intersection during a Christmas parade with a big wad of tobacco in his mouth’?
According to Parks and Recreation director Carlene Brown, her employees will adjust to the tobacco ban the same way they adjusted to the smoking ban. Given the information she received, she wants that adjustment for the health of her employees.
While talking to hospital officials Brown said she was told that statistics point to a decrease in the number of smokers once a smoking ban is placed at work. Specifically, one third will choose to quit within the first year and by three years, the workforce will be almost 100 percent non-smoking.
Given the benefits of quitting, she was told the hospital is considering changing from a smoke-free building to a smoke-free campus. At that time, smoking will not be allowed anywhere on the hospital grounds.
Also, Fire Chief Kevin Lawrence added that his department has been smoke free for several years, a decision he made well before the smoking ban passed by the state and immediately after he became chief eight years ago. After a brief period, employees adjusted and he believes they will adjust now.
Given the department directors’ support for a stricter policy, the decision passed with a vote of 5-1.
