Toyota Highlander tops SUV list-Buick Enclave Ford Taurus X also score well
For many families, three-row SUVs have become the hauler of choice. Designed to carry up to seven or eight people, they are versatile in balancing passengers and cargo space like minivans but have what many consider a less dowdy image. In addition, they come with all-wheel drive.
Consumer Reports recently tested 14 midsized three-row SUVs ranging in price from $34,270 for the Subaru Tribeca to $39,240 for the Buick Enclave. The Toyota Highlander, redesigned for 2008, earned the highest rating, slightly edging out the Honda Pilot and the more expensive Acura MDX.
TOYOTA HIGHLANDER ‘ PROS AND CONS
The Highlander ($38,578 as tested) scored high for its refinement, quiet interior, ride comfort, power, fuel economy and flexible and roomy second-row seat. A key to the Highlander’s polished feel is its comfortable ride, which isolates occupants from most bumps and remains steady and composed on the highway. Wind and engine noise are so subdued that CR’s testers noted mostly about road noise, which was fairly quiet.
Unlike some other three-row SUVs, the Highlander doesn’t feel overly bulky in turns. The body doesn’t lean too much. But the steering feels artificial and doesn’t offer much feedback. In an emergency-avoidance maneuver, the Highlander posted an unimpressive speed, but stability control helped keep it secure.
The smooth and spirited 270-horsepower, 3.5-liter V6 engine returned 18 mpg overall on regular fuel, good for such a big vehicle. CR found the five-speed automatic transmission silky smooth and very responsive. The Highlander can tow up to 5,000 pounds and towed a 3,500-pound test trailer to 60 mph in 15.8 seconds, the best time in this group.
But the Highlander is not without its drawbacks. The third-row seat doesn’t fold in sections as others do, which limits versatility. And while the handling is secure, it’s not very agile. Because reliability is still unknown, CR does not recommend the new Highlander.
RATING OTHER
THREE-ROW SUVS
The Buick Enclave and Ford Taurus X didn’t score as well as the Highlander, but both bested several other competitors in this test, including the Subaru Tribeca.
Buick’s new Enclave ($39,799 as tested) is a large, car-based SUV with a spacious third-row seat and sound ride and handling. A nicer interior finish, a quieter interior and a softer ride set it apart from its siblings, the GMC Acadia and the Saturn Outlook. Its weaknesses are rear visibility, awkward placement of some controls and unimpressive fuel economy. CR didn’t have reliability data for the Enclave at the time of testing, but the data for the similar Outlook and Acadia have been average.
The Ford Taurus X ($36,105 as tested) is a freshened version of the model formerly called the Freestyle. A bigger engine improves both performance and refinement, but fuel economy is worse. Access is easy, and the ride is comfortable. Standard stability control, which is new for 2008, dramatically improved the Taurus X’s at-the-limit handling. CR recommends the Taurus X based on the average reliability of the Freestyle.
The Subaru Tribeca ($34,720 as tested) is among the sportiest-handling SUVs tested. Pluses include a comfortable ride and its new, more powerful engine, which no longer requires premium fuel. With its 2008 freshening, Subaru has also eliminated the transmission problems CR complained about when testing the Tribeca in 2005. But it is not an ideal family vehicle because seating in all three rows is cramped. Reliability of the Tribeca has been better than average.
MORE SUVS,
FEWER MINIVANS
The number of three-row SUVs has dramatically increased while Ford and GM have been phasing out their minivan lines.
Overall, minivans still remain a good choice for families. As a group, they provide roomy, versatile interiors, with relatively decent fuel economy and handling.
Additional details about three-row SUVs and minivans are available at the Web site www.consumerreports.org.
