Senate selection process worked
Before I scrutinize the process of selecting Tennessee’s newest state senator, congratulations are in order.
It’s not often I say this, but congratulations to the Warren County Commission for selecting a qualified person to fill this important state government seat. And, of course, congratulations to attorney and new state Sen. Steve Roller, who I expect will do a fine job representing this community and the entire 14th District in Nashville.
Heading into Monday night’s vote, it was difficult to tell exactly how things would go down. Roller had to be considered one of the favorites, if for no other reason than the process of elimination.
Looking over the list of 15 candidates who participated in the Standard’s public forum, it didn’t take rocket science to determine who would not be getting the Senate appointment. And I don’t say that to slight any of the 15 forum participants because they all did a fine job and I admire their courage for trying to land this high-profile position.
Based on their performance in the public forum alone, I had the candidates ranked in this order: 1) Bill Zechman, 2) Tullahoma resident Lynn Sebourn, 3) Thomas Vaughn, 4) Bud Sharp, and 5) Steve Roller. I would put John Shields, George Smartt, and Manchester resident John Greeter on the honorable mention list, again based solely on their public forum performance.
If you let the process of elimination go to work, it takes only seconds to whittle the top eight into two finalists.
Lynn Sebourn, Thomas Vaughn and Bud Sharp lean too much to the right to be appointed by a Warren County Commission that doesn’t have a single declared Republican among its 22 members. So those three were out.
George Smartt doesn’t necessarily connect well with other commissioners, despite serving for 17 years on the county commission. He often went toe-to-toe with other commissioners on tax increase issues and I don’t think hard feelings were entirely avoided.
John Shields spoke well and made some solid points, but he came from political obscurity. Perhaps this will serve as a springboard for future political endeavors, but it wasn’t enough this time.
John Greeter boasts strong political ties and a successful business career, but I couldn’t envision a scenario where this 70-something from Coffee County gained the Senate appointment from our county commission.
That left Roller and Zechman as the last two logical heavyweights standing, although this showdown was far from certain. Based on the buzz I heard from the Fran Marcum camp, I thought she might be able to work her way into the mix.
Marcum, who lives in Coffee County, was apparently able to overcome the ‘outsider’ obstacle by being wealthy. I heard several people say she deserves the appointment because she ‘has the money to run a seven-county campaign.’ I guess it was because of this money, she was able to milk three votes from commissioners in the opening round before she was eliminated.
However, with the overwhelming sentiment to appoint a Warren County resident to fill this spot, that left Roller and Zechman as the last ones standing. Even though commissioners couldn’t break their deadlock and decide on either Roller or Zechman on Monday night, I still left that meeting with a degree of satisfaction. Either way, I knew Warren County would be in capable hands.
Probably the most appropriate thing to trumpet is that the process worked. We were fortunate to have an abundance of qualified candidates seeking the nomination, and fortunate to have a county commission to make an informed and intelligent decision.
James Clark is editor of the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].
