The disadvantage of being appointed
I talked to a gentlemen from Coffee County on Tuesday who expressed great interest in running for the state Senate seat vacated by Jerry Cooper. However, this man told me he had no desire to appear before the Warren County Commission this Monday in an effort to be appointed to the position.
He would never get a fair shake, he said. The Warren County Commission would never appoint a candidate from outside this county, he believes.
While I tend to be of that thinking myself, I’ve learned over the years that it’s difficult to grasp the phenomenon that is the Warren County Commission. I never underestimate the commission’s ability to do something completely baffling.
That said, this Coffee County man is going to bypass all attempts for a one-year appointment to the state Senate. He has his sights set on the general election in November 2008. He believes this is a much better long-term strategy.
This is a direct contrast to the column I wrote last week that indicated the person appointed this Monday will have a significant advantage at the polls in November. While I don’t intend to backtrack from that stance, it never hurts to examine the other point of view.
For starters, there is the belief that the appointed person will not only be dealt a seat in the state Senate, but he or she will be dealt a straight flush of resentment. Other counties not involved in the selection process ‘ which are six of the seven counties in the district ‘ will feel a certain amount of animosity toward this person because he or she was given the job by a mere 13 people.
It will be easy to find ways to dislike this appointed senator because it will be a person who is handed the job. The only real requirements are that you’re over 30, have lived here for at least a year, and haven’t stabbed anyone. Outside of that, if you have 13 friends on the county commission, presto, you’re a state senator.
Truth be told, it’s a natural reaction to hold a certain amount of resentment toward this process. If you’re not invited to the party, you’re going to have some ill feelings about the select few who are.
But essentially all of Warren County, minus 24 people, are in this same boat. We’re left out of the process too, stuck without a vote and up election creek without a paddle. Warren County residents could feel alienated as well, especially if commissioners make a bone-head move in this appointment.
However, I’m not going to succumb to this negative thinking. I have confidence commissioners will appoint a first-rate candidate, a person with character and charisma who will be easy to support in November.
The second hurdle any appointed candidate will have to clear is at least a four-month disadvantage in fundraising. Since it’s now illegal for members of the General Assembly to raise funds while they’re in session, any appointed candidate will have to wait probably until the end of April to organize any fundraising efforts.
That layoff is going to hurt (unless the appointed candidate is extremely wealthy) because a serious election campaign is going to require a great deal of money. By my calculations, which are far from scientific, I figure it will cost no less than $210,000 to mount a seven-county campaign.
While the resentment factor and the fundraising stipulations are two drawbacks, I still believe nothing trumps the power of incumbency.
Anyone who ever played King of the Mountain as a kid knows what I’m talking about. It’s far easier to win a battle when you’re on top as opposed to being the one clawing up the hill.
James Clark is editor of the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or be e-mail at [email protected].
