Skip to content

Commissioners seeking Senate must step down-Law generates controversy among officials

A section of Tennessee Code Annotated which requires any county commissioner to step down should he or she accept the nomination for the state Senate seat vacated by Jerry Cooper is causing a firestorm of controversy among local officials.

Some commissioners are challenging the validity of the state law, even going so far as to contact the State Attorney General’s office for an opinion.

The code in question, TCA 5-5-102 (c)(3), reads as follows:

‘If any member of the county legislative body accepts the nomination as a candidate for the office of county mayor, sheriff, trustee, register, county clerk, assessor of property, judge of a court of general sessions or seat in the general assembly, when such office is being filled by the county legislative body, such member shall automatically become disqualified to continue in office as a member of the county legislative body, and a vacancy on the body shall exist.’

County Executive John Pelham says that both the legal counsel of the County Technical Assistance Service (CTAS) and county attorney Larry Stanley have ruled that this code does apply to the appointment process the Warren County Commission will be conducting at its regular meeting Monday night.

Pelham said some commissioners are concerned because this information came to light only recently, but noted he tried to make it known to as many commissioners as possible, particularly those who had expressed an interest in the appointment.

Commissioners George Smartt and Bill Zechman have both openly expressed interest in the seat. If the are nominated Monday, and accept that nomination, they will no longer be commissioners, by law.

‘It was a question I asked early on that generated this,’ Pelham said. ‘I asked the CTAS representative if a commissioner could vote for himself. After looking into this, CTAS got back with me and informed me of this code.’

Pelham said after hearing that one commissioner had contacted the State Attorney General’s office for an opinion on this code, that he personally contacted that office as well, and was told by a representative that he should follow the advice of the CTAS lawyers and county attorney Stanley, both of whom had case law to back it up.

‘We acknowledge that a written opinion by the Attorney General would supersede anything else,’ Pelham said. ‘But we haven’t received that, so we have to go by this law. Personally I wish we didn’t have to, but we do.’

Pelham did say there is a way a commissioner could regain his seat if he failed to be appointed. Currently the method for replacing a commissioner who has stepped down is for the other commissioner in his district to nominate a replacement. According to Pelham, there is nothing to prevent the nomination of the former commissioner to the seat, but it would have to pass a vote from the full commission.

Though Pelham was prevented from setting up a dry run on the appointment process by state regulations which prohibited calling a meeting of the full commission without a five day notice, he was advised he could send out a letter outlining the appropriate procedure for selecting the replacement, which has already been mailed out. This letter includes the pertinent section of TCA 5-5-102 (c)(3) and also advises commissioners that any commissioner accepting nomination will forfeit his or her position on the commission and at that point will be asked to leave his or her designated seat and become a member of the audience.

Pelham said that legal requirement would be adhered to Monday night unless he was advised otherwise.

‘Barring a written opinion from the State Attorney General’s office changing this, which I don’t think we will receive from what I was told in my conversation with that office, we will follow the requirements set out in this code,’ Pelham said. ‘Once a commissioner accepts the nomination they will be asked to leave their seat and move into the audience.’

Pelham also pointed out this requirement could present another unique situation which will affect the number of votes required to approve the appointment, since more than one commissioner has expressed an interest in the nomination.

‘We could see a significant change in the makeup of our commission Monday night,’ Pelham said. ‘Each commissioner that accepts the nomination and steps down will reduce the size of our 24-member commission by one, so the number required for a majority will change accordingly.’

Pelham said in that case, after all the nominations are in, the appropriate number of votes required for appointment will be announced before any votes are cast in the initial round of voting.

Leave a Comment