Iraq: Only kind of horrible
Four and a half years since President Bush declared “Mission Accomplished” in Iraq, victory is again being proclaimed. “The Surge is working,” has become the latest catch phrase from chest-pounding Republican editorialists. Although oddly reluctant to actually pronounce the name of the mighty warlord Bush, GOP presidential candidates promise more aggressive prosecution of the war, ad infinitum. A front-page article in The New York Times solicitously warns Democrats that by criticizing the war, “they run the risk that Republicans will use those critiques to attack the party’s nominee in the election as defeatist and lacking faith in the American military.”
Gosh, you think? For ordinary citizens, it’s almost as hard recalling previous triumphal moments — the capture of Saddam Hussein, Iraq’s parliamentary elections, Saddam’s execution, Darth Cheney’s 2005 announcement of the Iraqi insurgency’s “last throes” — as keeping straight exactly whom we’re fighting, and why.
Recently, The Washington Post’s respected military correspondent Thomas Ricks reported that U.S. commanders in Baghdad “now portray the intransigence of Iraq’s Shiite-dominated government as the key threat facing the U.S. effort in Iraq, rather than Al Qaeda terrorists, Sunni insurgents or Iranian-backed militias.” Unless the Baghdad government agrees to share power with Sunni rivals soon, Army Lt. Gen. Raymond T. Odierno told Ricks, “We’re going to have to review our strategy.”
A few days later, the White House and Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki announced an agreement that would keep 50,000 American soldiers in Iraq for “coming generations.” Never mind that President Bush has no more constitutional authority to dictate U.S. policy beyond 2008 than my basset hound, Fred. If anything’s clear, it’s that one right hand has no idea what the other right hand’s doing.
Anonymous State Department officials told Ricks that criticizing the Maliki government was the Pentagon’s way of shifting blame if things go wrong. “That’s their out,” one diplomat said. Indeed, a friend of mine who saw heavy combat in Saigon during the Tet offensive sees ominous parallels between today’s lionization of Gen. David Petraeus and similarly worshipful treatment given Gen. William C. Westmoreland in 1968. He fears U.S. policymakers have again deluded themselves about the capacities of friend and foe.
It’s crucial to understand that Petraeus’ surge hasn’t so much defeated insurgents as bought them off with guns and money. Operating according to the traditional Arab understanding that “the enemy of my enemy is my friend,” the United States has basically created its own Sunni and Shiite militias. Upwards of 192 “concerned local citizens groups” have been armed, trained and paid $300 a month each to guard their own (ethnically cleansed) neighborhoods. On the tacit understanding that Americans will soon be leaving, U.S. troops basically monitor the boundaries.
In Chicago or Los Angeles, we’d call it a protection racket. The implicit bargain’s this: Keep your powder dry, and we’ll be gone. Then you can cut each other’s throats if you like. “When the U.S. leaves, what we’ll have are two armies,” one prominent Shiite politician told McClatchy newspapers’ Leila Fadel. “One who’s loyal to the government and one not loyal.”
It’s also traditional in the Middle East that each group anticipates and fears betrayal by all the others. Many think Iraq could degenerate into a warlord state like Sudan, with local gangs and tribes ascendant and no central government worth the name.
But it’s also true that peace, by whatever means, can grow habitual. For now, Petraeus’s “surge” has bought some time. If only somebody in Washington or Baghdad knew what to do with it.
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette columnist Gene Lyons can be reached at [email protected].
