School board members ponder building options
Warren County School Board members have been presented with a number of options on how to alleviate school overcrowding issues amid increasing enrollment.
A number of factors have played a part in this steady influx of new students, including Gov. Phil Bredesen’s pre-K program, which has already added 140 students and is expected to continue to grow as Bredesen pushes for universal pre-K throughout the state. Along with pre-K, which basically adds a grade to all elementary schools, the system is also experiencing a general increase in enrollment across the board.
The school board solicited and received estimates from Upland Design Group, the company which designed and supervised construction of the new Centertown School. A number of possible alternatives were presented at November’s school board meeting, including building a new middle school, a new elementary school, a second high school, and housing the new Ninth Grade Academy in its own facility.
A second high school appears popular among many School Board members because of the over 1,800 students there. However, officials say the high school is one of the few schools not facing overcrowding issues at this time.
After hearing the reports and discussing the issues at recent meetings, some School Board members outlined at least some of their preferences, while others say they don’t have enough information at this point.
Board member Mike Holland said he wants to look at all the angles before making any decisions.
‘I want to get some more information, talk to some more people, and then maybe narrow it down to two, three or four ideas the board could look at,’ said Holland. ‘And then maybe have some town hall meetings and get some public input as well. This is something we don’t need to make a snap decision on.’
However, Holland did endorse one issue
‘The only thing I know for sure is I don’t want to do anything with the K-8 out in the county,’ Holland said. ‘We don’t need to do anything with that.’
Though he realizes funding is going to be an issue, School Board chairman John Turner says there are some areas he feels need to be addressed, particularly the idea of a second high school.
‘On the building projects that need to come up pretty quickly, I think we have no alternative but to consider a second high school,’ Turner said. ‘Because our numbers are up close to 2,000, and that’s just too many to have in one location.’
Turner says he wants to keep the elementary schools K-8 and doesn’t support the idea building another middle school and moving students from elementary schools to reduce overcrowding.
‘We need to get away from middle school syndrome,’ Turner said. ‘The middle school we have does a great job, but I’d like to see the schools out in the community stay K-8.’
Turner says he would rather build another elementary school and deal with rezoning.
‘I don’t really support the Ninth Grade Academy either,’ Turner said, noting that even though there may be some negative influences, he feels ninth-graders can learn a lot from upperclassmen. ‘I just don’t think it’s going to work out the way they think it’s going to.’
Larry Judkins said he has at least three issues he has already decided on as a board member, taking a different tack than Turner on the Ninth Grade Academy, but agreeing on other items.
‘I’m personally for the Ninth Grade Academy,’ Judkins said. ‘I’m for smaller school enrollments. I’m not for moving the seventh- and eighth-grades out of the elementary schools out in the community. I’d rather see them stay K-8. I guess that’s my three biggest issues.
‘There’s a lot of options, so I guess we’ll just have to wade through it and see what happens,’ Judkins added. ‘I am for a smaller high school, even if we have to have two. I will say that.’
Judkins is also aware any decision is going to require some major funding.
‘Of course the bottom line is going to be cost,’ Judkins said, ‘based on what the County Commission will appropriate.’
Board member Edd Cantrell said there is still significant work and study needed before the board makes a move.
‘The big thing, of course, is the crowding in the high school,’ said Cantrell. ‘We’re trying to get it cut down. I’ve always said if you get over 1,000 at a high school you lose the identity of the students.
‘Other than that, we haven’t gone too far,’ Cantrell continued. ‘We’ve discussed many things. As far as a new high school is concerned, I think we have some overcrowding in some of these elementary schools that we’re going to have to take care of first.’
Bob Young, like Holland, said there should be more discussion before the board makes any definite decision.
‘It’s been discussed about having two high schools, but Mr. Clemow (Derrick Clemow of Upland Design Group) says the high school is not where our problem’s at,’ said Young. ‘It’s in the lower grades. We are running over at the seams at about all our schools.’
Newest board member Gordon McGee Jr. had a somewhat different take on how to provide more space.
‘I like the idea of trying to utilize any of our facilities we’re not using to maximum potential,’ said McGee. ‘There’s a large portion of the middle school we’re not using effectively. We have a building over at Bobby Ray that needs some repair work that we can use. It needs to be updated to ADA compliance and to have some other issues addressed. We have some facilities that we could use a little better.’
McGee said using existing space makes sense not only logistically, but economically as well. ‘It would save the county money,’ he said. ‘But I also see the need for us having to create more room at the elementary level and also at the high school level. I realize that is a concern. If that’s what we need to do, to build another school, whether it be a middle school or a high school or an elementary school, then that’s what I want to do. But we really need to use what we have first.’
McGee says he is not necessarily against making outlying elementary schools pre-K-6 instead of K-8, although he understands it is controversial.
‘Growing up in this county I realize they hold on to those community schools very dearly and I can understand that,’ said McGee. ‘But if it’s a situation that’s going to give the best education and, I hate to use this, but the best bang for the buck, then I think it’s an option we really seriously need to consider, and look at it from the standpoint of what’s best for the kids, not what’s best for the pocketbook.’
