Skip to content

McFadden, Tebow top Heisman list

With Florida sophomore quarterback Tim Tebow apparently holding a slight edge in the Heisman balloting, this year could be one of the closest on record as no clear-cut winner has emerged.

Tebow, should he win, would be the first sophomore ever to win the award which has been given out annually since Jay Berwanger of Chicago U. first received the trophy in 1935. He would also be only the third player to win the award playing on a team with three or more losses.

Tebow certainly has the stats to back up his reputation as he has thrown for over 3,100 yards and 29 touchdowns, plus he’s run for 838 and 22 touchdowns, giving him an NCAA record of 51 total TDs. Voters may also consider he accomplished these feats while competing in the SEC, which is known for its rugged defenses.

Speaking of the SEC, Darren McFadden, junior Arkansas running back who placed second in the Heisman voting last year behind Ohio State quarterback Troy Smith, may have something to say about the award. First off, he ripped the LSU defense, on national TV with all 923 of the Heisman voters watching, for 206 yards and three touchdowns, even throwing a touchdown pass before his ‘we got the wood right here baby’ postgame sound bite alongside his former coach Houston Nutt. He also set an SEC record by ripping the South Carolina defense for 323 yards rushing.

With Tebow and McFadden leading the consensus Heisman race, unless Missouri quarterback Chase Daniel spoils the party, voters may make their decisions by comparing these two SEC supermen. If this is the case, then look for Tebow to take the trophy. Why, you ask? I’ll give you three good reasons.

First, Tebow has rushed for seven more scores than McFadden as he provides a double threat on every play to either run or pass. Yes, I said rushing. Tebow got to the end zone seven more times than the Razorbacks’ star running back. This isn’t including his 29 touchdown tosses.

Second, Tebow has been more consistent in performances aside from his minus-14 yards rushing in Florida’s 42-30 loss to Georgia. McFadden, while having huge games against Carolina and Alabama, has laid some eggs, rushing for just 43 yards against Auburn, 88 against Mississippi State and 61 yards against Florida International.

Third, Heisman winners generally come from winning teams, explaining why Daniel, who had one additional game to charm the Heisman voters last night, could be a dark horse given his wildly successful Mizzou squad. In the case of Tebow, he has three losses while, despite their big win against LSU, the Razorbacks have four. A slight difference, yes, but a slight difference in a year where it could come down to a handful of votes.

The only things I see playing against Tebow this year would be the fact McFadden is known to the voters from last year when he got 45 first-place votes, following 801 received by Smith. And, the fact McFadden is an upperclassman compared to Tebow and will likely be an immediate impact back in the NFL could catch the eye of some voters.

As for the also-rans, the Heisman will be a three-way race. Sorry to Colt Brennan of Hawaii who reset the record books. Play a competitive schedule next time. Sorry Mike Hart of Michigan. You forfeit any chance of winning anything when you open your season with a loss to Appalachian State. And sorry to Brian Brohm of Louisville. Your brother was better.

Leave a Comment