Skip to content

Will TDA stand firm on ‘pest plant’ rule?

I attended the TDA plant pest Rulemaking Hearing Monday so I could tell you what was decided. For the moment, mimosa is off the list, but will be reconsidered in two years. Variegated privet is back on the list of plants to be removed from production. Sale of Elaeagnus pungens or thorny Elaeagnus is extended to 2011 for retail sales and 2013 for wholesale sales.

Anything is possible yet. Twelve nursery producers attended from our area with six addressing the group. Our industry basically asked for the rule to be tabled to allow more time to gather any research data in support of the invasiveness of the crops. We feel some plants have been added without research to support them being invasive.

Charles Curtis was good enough to come and expressed concern over the economic impact this rule would have on the local economy and with the nurseries whose sales would be impacted. He suggested a solution might be to prevent the sale of the plants in question in Tennessee and other states that consider the plants invasive. He hoped TDA would wait for statistics to prove the invasiveness of each plant being considered.

If those plants were no longer produced in Tennessee nurseries, would their population in the wild diminish? No. And by the way, what would grow there if I could wiggle my nose and cause the invasive plants to disappear? I have never witnessed fertile soil remain vacant.

Nurseries grow the plants in question from rooted cuttings. The stock plants and the young liners do not produce seed in nurseries, but they do in the landscape. Privet and elaeagnus have escaped into the wild by birds eating the seed produced by plants in the landscape.

Nothing has been suggested about removing all the privet and Elaeagnus from the landscape, the wild or killing the birds. It is easier to tell a farmer that he can’t raise the crop his grandfather did, that will effect his income. Will a law soon force private landowners to cut down their hedges and flowering pear? How else to prevent more from escaping into the wild?

I have personally experienced problems with privet, elaeagnus, multiflora rose, kudzu, bamboo, poison ivy, redcedars, burning bush, the sawbriar smilax, callery pear seedlings, thistle, bittersweet (Celastrus), Carolina buckthorn (Rhamnus caroliniana) and bermudagrass, etc. Unmanaged land owned by absentee landowners frequently develop pest weeds. I know there are thickets of privet that can not be walked or crawled through.

While these plants are easy and fast to produce, they also transplant well with little mortality and they tolerate situations that make them useful; they seldom require pesticides. There is a demand for them in ecosystems other than in Tennessee. Our industry is serving a purpose by providing them. The so-called alternatives are not as easy or as economical to produce, do not survive as well, and not as pest free.

Why are we having to defend our market to our own state? We would not grow it if there was not a demand.

What is invasive here is not there and visa versa.

An hour after it began, it was over. They informed us they would let us know in 75 days.

‘ Mark your calendar for a Basic Field Weed Control mtg Nov 27, 6-9 p.m. at the Warren County Administrative Office Building. I plan to provide ideas for sprayer set-up, neat equipment ideas, those that require less effort, for the lazy sprayer. I will explain calibration so well that a caveman can do it. Much effort will be devoted to explaining timing, activation, application, etc. ‘ suggestions to improve the success of your preemergent herbicides (time and investment).

Leave a Comment