Skip to content

Two Slatton jurors claim injustice-Say lone holdout was determined to prevent conviction

Jurors in the Joy Slatton theft case believe there was a Trojan Horse in their midst, with two of the 12-member panel suggesting there was a female juror who had no plans to convict the former trustee of anything ‘ regardless of the evidence.

‘The prosecutor laid it out there where even a blind person could see it,’ said one of the jurors who spoke Sunday with the Southern Standard on condition of anonymity. ‘It was obvious from the get-go that she wasn’t going to budge and she had some kind of outside interest in making sure Mrs. Slatton wasn’t convicted of anything. Let me put it this way, if we were on a ship that was going down and there were 11 life jackets, I can tell you for sure who wouldn’t be getting one.’

The jury returned deadlocked after eight hours of deliberation as Slatton was accused of paying her daughter, Rene Brown, for time she did not work while employed at the trustee’s office between 2001 and 2005. The defense maintained Brown had the sick time. However, the state said she could not have accumulated that much time and that Slatton was abusing her office to keep her daughter on the payroll.

Two jurors who spoke with the Standard said they voted to convict Slatton on the felony and misdemeanor charges. Slatton faced around 30 criminal counts.

‘It seemed the state had the ammunition and all the defense had was smoke,’ one juror said. ‘I think everybody on the jury realized what Mrs. Slatton did was wrong and that the taxpayers were wronged.’

One juror said the vote was split on the felony counts but as the votes continued the number of votes for conviction rose.

‘I think some of the jurors were against the felony counts because they didn’t want Mrs. Slatton to go to prison, but someone pointed out sentencing wasn’t our business, we were just to decide guilt or innocence,’ the juror said. ‘That’s when some came over to convict on the felony charges but it became apparent that the one juror wouldn’t budge. That’s when we went off the felony charges and started debating the misdemeanor charges.’

The jurors agreed that it was soon 11-1 to convict on the misdemeanor charges but the one woman would not budge.

‘She kept saying the trustee’s office was Joy’s house and she could do what she wanted to with it and that she wasn’t going to convict her on that,’ the juror said. ‘She said that so many times that we were sick of it and then she got defensive and told us she wasn’t the one on trial.’

Jurors finally emerged from the jury room hoping for the judge to give some direction, but instead a mistrial was declared.

‘We did Warren County a disservice and it makes me ashamed,’ one juror said. ‘This is a case that never should have been tried here just for this reason. Had it been tried anywhere else, Mrs. Slatton would have been convicted because the evidence is there. What we really wanted to see more than anything is for the taxpayers to get paid back for the money they had ripped off.’

Both jurors agreed Slatton’s testimony was damaging to the defense, noting 11 of the 12 jurors found little doubt she was at least guilty of the misdemeanors.

‘This was better than DNA. We were 99.9 percent sure,’ the juror said. ‘But this lady wasn’t moving for anything.’

Following the trial, the jurors said they saw the lone holdout stick her head in the door of the courtroom at the county government building and say something to the defendant, a move which infuriated the four jurors who saw the act after her unwillingness to change her vote.

‘That was just the icing on the cake,’ one of the jurors said. ‘Now, afterwards, we find there was a connection there between this juror and the defense. It’s just wrong and it shouldn’t have happened.’

The recollections by the two jurors interviewed was backed up by two other jurors contacted by the Southern Standard.

In light of the revelations, special prosecutor Glenn Funk said it is highly likely he will seek a re-trial.

‘The state of Tennessee takes public corruption cases very seriously,’ Funk said. ‘I will be discussing this case with the TBI, the comptroller’s office and our witnesses and make a decision in the near future, but at this point I expect to try it again.’

As for jury selection, Funk said it is tough in an area the size of Warren County, to find 12 jurors who are not connected to someone involved.

‘It would basically be impossible to find someone who isn’t in some way connected to either Slatton or the defense,’ Funk said.

Defense attorney Michael Galligan said he knows of no connection between his client and the lone female holdout which would have prompted her to vote against conviction purely due to person reasons.

‘She was the one who was right,’ Galligan said, noting he appreciated the service of all the jurors but that the lone holdout understood the defense’s theory of the case. ‘The system only works if each juror can stand up for what they think and that’s what this brave juror did.’

Given the fact none of the verdicts were accepted by the court since the jury was hung, Slatton will likely face trial on all the original counts except the ones involving alleged wrongful payments to her daughter, Gaye Lentz, which were dismissed due to the statute of limitations.

Leave a Comment