Skip to content

Slatton’s trialexposed issues

The Joy Slatton trial has exposed problems with not only the way our elected county offices do business but also in the jury system, in a case where the taxpayers of Warren County are the big losers.

If the defense theory is correct and an elected official can do anything he or she wants with taxpayer money since they are sent there by the voters, then something needs to be changed ‘ and quick. If an office holder can, as was said in open court by our county attorney, ‘close her office to get her hair done and that we can’t do one thing about it’ then we need to make sure that loophole in the system is closed.

I don’t believe election to an office gives a person a license to make questionable disbursements of public money, no matter how liberally you interpret the law. The only check on governmental power shouldn’t come just once every four years at the ballot box. It should be a regular check where there is daily accountability to the taxpayers.

There must be a uniform accounting of sick and vacation leave given the fact right now it’s up in the air. According to the policy manual I was shown this past week, it’s still up to the office holder how much sick and vacation time an employee can receive. Actually, an office holder could elect to give no sick time if they wanted, or they could elect to give endless sick time.

If you paid attention to the court case, there was controversy of whether longtime employees were capped for at 60 days accumulated sick leave due to the 1997 office holder agreement with the county. Some only give sick time beginning with the 60-day cap of 1997 while other office holders disregard 1997 like it didn’t happen and are calculating sick leave on the actual start date of the employee.

What this means to the county is there’s hundreds of thousands of dollars in limbo out there when it comes to accrued sick leave, which generally carries over. However, no one really knows exactly how much we are liable for since everyone keeps their own records, that is, if office holders are actually keeping records.

Folks, we’ve already had one office holder put on trial for this. Don’t you think it’s time we put some kind of uniformity to it. Let’s demand to have an accounting of how much time is owed each employee and let’s put it in writing and put it in a vault at the accounting office. Then, next time there’s a question, it will be there in black and white with no one able to claim a Watergate-type scandal like was claimed in the Slatton trial.

While we can fix the sick leave accounting problem, the jury issue is systemic and likely can’t be fixed. From what I’ve heard from jurors, the lone juror holding out on the Slatton side was predisposed not to vote guilty on any count regardless of the evidence. This is their opinion, and since I wasn’t in the jury room, I’m relying on their version of events that a biased juror slipped in under the radar.

However, this is nothing new. I’ve seen biased jurors seated many times, jurors who had an agenda when they asked to be part of the jury and I knew it when I saw them in the jury box. While it’s been rare to produce a hung jury, I’ve seen biased jurors swing the vote of a jury before.

In the end, it’s up to the state or defense to weed out these jurors during jury selection. And, in the case of the special prosecutor in this case, he’s from out of town and had no idea of the connections jurors may have with the defense. Folks, anyone can say they can put aside their personal feelings and decide a case on proof. It’s another thing to actually do it.

Duane Sherrill is a reporter for the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].

Leave a Comment