DA believes Winkler was going to kill herself, her kids
|
Dunavant, a former defense attorney, said a defense attorney’s job is different from a prosecutor’s and not just because they’re on different sides of the courtroom.
‘The job of a prosecutor is to seek the truth and put it in front of 12 good people,’ Dunavant said. ‘The job of a defense attorney is not to seek the truth. It’s to get their client off, by hook or crook, by lie, deception, subterfuge, confusion, whatever it is. That’s their job.
‘And we understand that,’ he said. ‘They have different standards and different considerations and different … ethical considerations than we do. We have … a higher ethical requirement on us as prosecutors, and you know why, because we have the burden of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt because every day, it’s our job to take people’s freedom.’
Winkler was charged with first-degree murder in the shotgun slaying of her husband, Matthew Winkler, the minister at Selmer’s Fourth Street Church of Christ. The jury instead convicted her of voluntary manslaughter in April.
Winkler has since served a brief sentence in the case and is now living and working in Warren County. She is also fighting for custody of her three young daughters.
Dunavant has answered some questions people have had about the case.
Question: This case was being watched live nationally. There was one day when a man called the clerk’s office and threatened the prosecution. How did you deal with the criticism knowing your every action was being watched and judged?
Answer: The nature of the threat was the gentleman who called had been watching the trial and was not pleased with the way we were prosecuting the case and (said) that if we didn’t do better, he was going to come down and do something about it … We took that to mean do something violent or do something disruptive.
Listen, people have been second guessing our prosecution of this case before we put on the trial, during the trial and after the trial, and all I can say is we’re the prosecutors and they’re not. And we know what we’re doing, and we did a good job.
Question: What was your strategy for prosecuting the case?
Answer: Our strategy was to put on the necessary witnesses and physical evidence and exhibits to show and prove that Mary killed her husband in premeditation. Again, getting up in the early morning hours and getting a shotgun out of the closet, loading it, chambering one and shooting your sleeping husband in the back seems like awfully good evidence of premeditation.
So, our strategy was to put on the evidence from the TBI at the crime scene, the evidence of the medical examiner of the cause of death, including the wound to the back, to put on evidence from the Alabama Bureau of Investigation and the TBI of Mary’s confession. And that’s what they were ‘ they were confessions. She admitted she did it, and she admitted that her ugly came out and she was just a mean, bad, evil woman and that she had been thinking about doing it for years.
She confessed to thinking about it prior to the event. That’s called premeditation when you think about doing it before you do it. She even talked about how loud she thought the gun was going to be when it went off. How much better premeditation evidence could we have?
We knew that the jurors were going to ask the question why. And if you remember, that was Matthew’s last word on this earth … We didn’t have to prove it. But by God, we had some pretty good evidence of why she did it.
She was kiting checks. Now, here’s a woman who claims that her husband controls everything from the way she wears her hair to the way she eats too much because she’s getting too fat, to the way that they had sex because he made her do things she didn’t want to. And he controls her phone conversations and her friends and he controls everything.
And yet, here’s a woman who controlled every check in that household. … If she was really the beat down, submissive, poor, pitiful Mary that was picked on and controlled at every turn by her husband, wouldn’t he be writing the checks? Wouldn’t he be controlling the finances because she would be too stupid or too incompetent or not trustworthy enough to write the checks?
And yet what did we see at the trial? We saw unrefuted evidence that Mary had multiple accounts, she paid all the bills. She was even allowed to go and buy the pizza that they had the night before he was killed. Well, my God, if she’s getting a little too fat, why did he let her write the check for the pizza? … It’s clear that she was not abused. She was not controlled. Her whole abuse excuse was a lie and a farce …
I’ll say this, when your husband is a Church of Christ minister in a small town, and you’ve been committing financial fraud, and the phone calls from the bank are getting quicker and more frequent and more urgent and finally the bank teller and the bank officers are telling you, ‘You know, Mary, what you’re doing is illegal, and we’re going to have to tell Matthew about it.’ We put that timeline right up there on the board. You could see it getting closer. She’s taking checks in that are bogus, she’s running them through, then she’s cashing them out. She knows what she’s doing.
Maybe she just had a spending problem. Maybe she’s like a lot of people in the world and she liked to live beyond her means. Maybe she was dishonest with her husband. She was stealing all this money and kiting all these checks. He didn’t have a clue. And the closer it got from December and then January and then, ‘Mary, it’s February, you need to come on in and make these checks right.’ And here we are in March, ‘Mary, we’re just going to have to have a talk about this with your husband now. We want you and Matthew to come on in because his name’s on the account, too.’
Well, can’t you imagine that night before she shot him that morning? She’s desperate. She’s freaking out. She’s going to have to explain to her Church of Christ minister husband and probably the church why she is a criminal and she is a liar and she is a person who’s committed financial fraud. It’s going to be embarrassing. Her husband may lose his job. She may go to jail. So, you know what? She’s been battling to do it for years. She’s been thinking about it for years, and finally, you know what? Now is the time to do it because tomorrow morning we got to get up and we’ve got to go explain to the bank what’s going on and Matthew’s going to find out, and Matthew’s not going to be happy. And you know what? I’m just going to kill him.
After the shooting
Dunavant: I would suggest to you that the evidence was clear that not only did she make up her mind that she was going to kill him when she did but she was going to end it for her children and herself, too. She kills him, and packs a pair of socks for her daughter, her youngest daughter. She scoops up all three children. She takes the shotgun and a box of shells with her in the minivan. Remember that box of shells? Remember that tackle box?
And I think we proved it in kind of a way that was implied. We didn’t come out and say it. I think (Assistant District Attorney) Walt (Freeland) asked Mary on cross examination: He said, ‘Mary, was anybody really coming back from Alabama’?
She had what? Less than $200 in cash, a pair of socks for her baby, a shotgun and a box of shells in a minivan. That’s it. She drove hundreds of miles to Jackson, Miss., spent one night, and then to Orange Beach, Ala., and was in a hotel the next night. She was running out of money. How was she going to feed her children? How was she going to get back to Tennessee? You know what she was going to do. She was going to kill her children and herself, and she was just going to do it at the beach instead of in Selmer, Tennessee. Now, that’s my own personal observation and opinion, which she never came out and admitted that. But that’s our speculation. We couldn’t prove it at trial.
But you think about it. Was Mary really coming back? No. And luckily the Orange Beach, Ala., Police Department did their job properly. And when the BOLO (be on the lookout) was put out and when the Amber alert was put out for those kids, that officer did the right thing, and he pulled that van over, and he probably prevented four more deaths.
Question: The shoe and the wig that the defense presented to support their claims of sexual abuse: Were those in the house when police went in to confiscate things – because someone said to me that she could have bought it afterward?
Answer: We don’t know. Let me tell you the circumstances under which the house was secured and where that evidence may or may not have come from … When police responded to the house and found Matthew’s body in the bedroom, of course, they secured the scene. They roped it off and they took measurements and photographs and DNA. They did all their evidence collection there at the house, and they didn’t just do it in the bedroom where he died. They went through every room and every closet, looking for evidence related to this crime of homicide.
Well, what would you think would be relevant to a homicide investigation? Blood. Weapons. And if you recall, they even took the family computer. … Because often the computer will have information on it that’s relevant to a homicide. If you recall, we all heard what was on that computer. (Pornographic images.)
So, they took his body and his clothing and the carpet that was under him and they took the pillow and the sheets that had blood on them and they took the computer. And they took his wallet and they took a photo, a family photograph for the Amber alert, and they took all the measurements of the scene and all the diagrams and all the photographs for evidence.
When the TBI was searching that house for evidence of a murder, a high heel shoe and a wig didn’t seem to be very relevant because at that time, they didn’t know Mary’s story. And I would suggest to you at that time, Mary didn’t even know her own story. I would suggest to you that, that story was manufactured by her defense attorneys after they had some time to meet with her in jail.
(Dunavant said Mary Winkler said nothing to police about Matthew Winkler making her wear a wig and shoes. Had that happened, the TBI could have gone back and looked for them, he said.)
At some time in 2007, after the house had already been released to the church by the TBI, after it had already been processed, and after everything was still in it, sometime later on, the defense team, Mr. Farese and Mr. Ballin, and I think even Mary, were allowed by the court to go back to the house and gather some of her personal belongings. And they were allowed to do that with a police escort.
What Mary went in and took from out of her closet or from under her bed or wherever, I don’t know. The police escort did not tell us as prosecutors that she went in and immediately grabbed for a shoe or a wig. As you recall, it was in a white, plastic Wal-Mart sack at trial. … I don’t know if it came from that house or was purchased by Mr. Farese or Mr. Ballin or came from their office or from some other store. It could have been in the house. But you can’t blame the TBI for not getting it. They didn’t know it was relevant.
And if she was the only one who knew it was relevant, and she went in, she knew exactly where it was. She could have very easily and privately secreted that out and done that in a way that not everybody could see. Regardless of all of that, the moment she got on the witness stand, and the moment she identified the shoe and identified the wig as being the very ones she was forced to wear, they became relevant evidence.
Question: I know you say the defense has a lot of leeway and aren’t bound by the same rules. But they can’t make up evidence, can they?
Answer: No, ma’am, they can’t. But we can’t prove they did or they didn’t.
Question: How did that affect the case?
Answer: I’m sure that it affected it dramatically. We were not aware of it. We had not anticipated it. Again, we had no reason to know in what way she would craft her defense or her story about abuse. We had no way of knowing that a wig and a shoe would be involved any more than a spaceship would be involved. Again, she could have said anything, and we just had to deal with it as it came.
It was certainly an important visual aid for the jury. I suppose it lent credibility to her testimony. It was a dramatic piece of evidence that clearly was calculated by Mr. Farese and Mr. Ballin to have an impact, and I think it probably did.

