Funk calls Stanley unindicted co-conspirator
Citing evidence that high-ranking members of local government knew of allegations of misconduct against Trustee Joy Slatton as far back as 2001 but took no action, Judge Allen Wallace dismissed several charges against the seven-term trustee on Wednesday, finding that the statute of limitations had already expired.
His dismissal came as special prosecutor Glenn Funk suggested he should have named county attorney Larry Stanley as an unindicted co-conspirator for not following up on information a crime was committed, which he and then-County Executive Carol Hamblen were given in 2001.
‘He (Stanley) was more of an unindicted co-conspirator,’ Funk told the court, noting the veteran attorney had been appointed to his post by Slatton’s father L.H. ‘Bud’ Barnes and that Stanley admitted being close friends of the family. ‘He was more of her protector.’
Special Judge Allen Wallace did not agree with Funk’s assessment of Stanley as a co-conspirator, noting he was dismissing the counts purely due to the statute of limitations.
The counts which were dismissed dealt specifically with Slatton’s daughter, Gaye Lentz, who is charged with being paid for time she did not work in the trustee’s office in 2001. Prosecutors maintain Lentz received several payroll checks after she left the trustee’s office to work at Nissan.
In light of the dismissal of those counts, Lentz’s attorney, Tim Pirtle, says he intends to ask for dismissal of the counts against his client given the court’s ruling in her mother’s case. Lentz is to be tried at a later date.
Judge Wallace dismissed the counts Wednesday afternoon at the conclusion of the prosecution’s case against Slatton after county payroll clerk Melonie Lanier testified she had informed not only her supervisor, Director of Accounts Linda Hillis, of her suspicions, but also then-County Executive Carol Hamblen and county attorney Larry Stanley.
‘I noticed Gaye was still on the payroll even after she had terminated her insurance due to taking a job at Nissan,’ Lanier testified, noting she told of her suspicions in 2001, which prompted a meeting with the county executive and county attorney.
Lanier would years later tell state comptroller fraud investigator Melody Wheeler of her suspicions about Lentz and her suspicions about fellow Slatton daughter and employee Rene Brown collecting a salary.
‘She (Lanier) said it was odd how some people can get paid and not come to work,’ Wheeler testified, noting the tip caused her to go to the trustee’s office every day for a few weeks to see if Brown was coming to work. ‘I went to the trustee’s office every day, but she (Brown) was not there but was being paid as if she was.’
In making his decision, Judge Wallace agreed with defense attorney Michael Galligan that the clock started ticking when Lanier reported the incidents involving Lentz in 2001, thereby outweighing any alleged attempt by Slatton to cover any crime. The statute of limitations on a misdemeanor is one year, and for a Class D felony is four years, meaning the indictments came too late.
Wallace admitted he is somewhat disturbed by evidence he heard regarding Lentz’s being paid after she went to work at Nissan. However, he also found the statute of limitations had passed. The amount of money Lentz received during the time in question was under $4,000.
County attorney Larry Stanley recalled the meeting about Lentz being paid after leaving the trustee’s office but said he speculated she was receiving either comp time or extra vacation time. Regardless, Stanley said he saw no evidence of wrongdoing.
‘It isn’t my job to follow up on that,’ Stanley said. ‘I told them if they can find some evidence of a crime, then come back and talk to me but I never saw them again about it. I assumed Ms. Lentz was getting sick leave or comp pay that she was owed.’
Stanley pointed out that Slatton held an elected office and, so long as she stayed in her budget, she was free to make the rules.
‘She could have given those girls 120 days sick leave a year and that would be her business because she was an elected official,’ Stanley said. ‘She could close the place down for the day and get her hair done and there’s nothing that could be done because it is an elected office. If the people didn’t like how things were done, they could elect someone else.’
The dismissal of the Lentz charges does not affect the Brown case, which allegedly happened during 2004-05 and involved an estimated $64,000 in county funds.
