Graduation rates calculated differently across America
“I think we need some truth in advertising,” Spellings said in an interview, referring to the hodgepodge of ways states now report graduation data.
States calculate their graduation rates using all sorts of methods, many of which critics say are based on unreliable information about school dropouts.
In statistics used by the state, Tennessee schools report a 77.9 percent graduation rate in the four years ending 2005, while federal accounting shows 68.5 percent.
Republicans and Democrats in Congress have drafted proposals to better gauge how well high schools are doing at getting students diplomas, and doing it on time. The changes are part of a rewrite of the No Child Left Behind education law, but that bill’s progress has stalled amid disputes over unrelated testing and teacher pay issues.
Spellings said if that standoff persists, her department has the power to address the reporting of graduation rates. “I think it can be done through regulations,” she said.
There is an overwhelming consensus among politicians, educators and academics that states must do a better job. Spellings pointed to a two-year-old agreement by the nation’s governors to adopt a common method of calculating high school graduation rates.
It calls for states to develop systems that track individual students throughout school and record whether they transfer, drop out or graduate. In general, students who graduate on time and with regular diplomas would count toward a state’s graduation rate. Research indicates students who take extra time to graduate or get alternatives to diplomas, such as a GED, generally don’t do as well in college or the work force.
So far, about dozen states are using a method like the one endorsed by the governors to report their graduation rates.
Under No Child Left Behind, states may use their own methods of calculating graduation rates and set their own goals for improving them. Critics say that’s a loophole.
Some states, for example, give themselves passing grades as long as they make any progress at all on graduation rates from year to year.
States’ methods of counting graduates also are flawed and lead to overestimates, according to reports by both the Education Trust, which advocates for poor and minority children, and the Alliance for Excellent Education, another group focused on the issue.
For example, Florida ‘ which does track individual students ‘ includes those who receive GED certificates in lieu of diplomas when calculating its high school graduation rate.
And New Mexico counts the number of enrolled 12th-graders who graduate as its rate. That is problematic, because most dropouts leave school before their senior year.
North Carolina used to report the percentage of graduates who completed high school on time, completely ignoring those who dropped out early. That gave the state a 95 percent graduation rate. When the state recently switched to the tracking method backed by the governors, its rate plummeted to 68 percent.
The federal government estimates the nation’s on-time graduation rate at about 70 percent. For minorities, it’s closer to 50 percent.
The Education Department uses a formula for estimating the graduation rate of each state by comparing diplomas given out against the enrollment figures for that class in earlier grades. In nearly all cases, the federal estimate is lower than the state-reported rate.
Graduation rates
HER WAY: If Congress doesn’t get the job done, Education Secretary Margaret Spellings says she’ll consider using her authority to require states to report high school graduation rates in a more uniform and accurate way.
HODGEPODGE DATA: States calculate their graduation rates using all sorts of methods, many of which critics say are based on unreliable information.
BILL STALLED: Congress has drafted proposals to better gauge how well high schools are doing at getting students diplomas. But the bill that includes these changes has stalled amid disputes over unrelated testing and teacher pay issues.
