District attorney speaks out in Winkler case
|
Winkler, 33, was convicted of voluntary manslaughter in April for shooting husband Matthew Winkler at their residence in Selmer in March 2006. She had faced a higher charge of first-degree murder.
District Attorney General Michael Dunavant told The Jackson Sun he felt statements Winkler gave police after her arrest were enough to prove she premeditated the killing, which must be proven in a first-degree murder case.
‘She confessed to thinking about it prior to the event,’ Dunavant said. ‘She even talked about how loud she thought the gun was going to be when it went off. How much better premeditation evidence could we have?
‘Getting up in the early morning hours and getting a shotgun out of the closet, loading it, chambering one (shell) and shooting your sleeping husband in the back seems like awfully good evidence of premeditation,’ he said.
Winkler’s attorney Steve Farese Sr., said he was disappointed in Dunavant’s statements, which he said were professionally unethical.
‘I have difficulty understanding his responses to many things,’ Farese told The Associated Press. ‘Many people read the newspaper and believe that because this is a person of position that it must be true.’
Dunavant said he and other prosecutors wanted to give evidence of a potential motive, even though by law they weren’t required to, because he knew jurors would want to have an idea why Winkler shot her husband.
Assistant District Attorney General Walt Freeland presented hours of testimony about the Winklers’ banking history, in hopes of proving Mary Winkler was falling into financial straits after falling victim to a check kiting scheme and was afraid to tell her husband.
Winkler herself testified that her husband was controlling and abused her physically, mentally and sexually, but Dunavant said her control of the family’s finances seemed to indicate otherwise.
‘If she was really the beat down, submissive, poor, pitiful Mary that was picked on and controlled at every turn by her husband, wouldn’t he be writing the checks’? Dunavant said.
Farese said Dunavant was ‘absolutely mistaken’ in suggesting Winkler and the defense team would have lied about the Winklers’ relationship.
‘It made no sense to us that someone would kill their husband to cover up inconsistencies in banking,’ he said. ‘It’s sad that this matter has degenerated into a situation which deludes the public’s perception of our justice system.’
Dunavant acknowledged that a wig and high-heeled shoe that the defense presented as evidence Winkler was forced to perform sexual acts against her will turned out to be a dramatic and important piece of visual evidence.
He said he and the authorities had no way of knowing to look for such pieces of evidence, and that Tennessee Bureau of Investigation agents wouldn’t have realized the items were significant bits of evidence if they did see them.
‘When the TBI was searching that house for evidence of a murder, a high-heel shoe and a wig didn’t seem to be very relevant because at that time, they didn’t know Mary’s story,’ Dunavant said.
Winkler is currently involved in a custody battle with her former husband’s parents over the couple’s three children.

