Skip to content

Did Slatton take taxpayer dollars?

Did Slatton take taxpayer dollars?

Special prosecutor Glenn Funk contends Slatton abused her authority.
Suggesting one of the state’s star witnesses has an ax to grind against embattled former county Trustee Joy Slatton, defense attorney Michael Galligan maintained guess work should not be used to help put his client behind bars on the opening day of trial for the seven-term county official.

‘She is trying to guess my client into the penitentiary,’ said Galligan of the testimony from former trustee employee Donna Pelham, who estimated how much work Slatton’s daughter and employee Rene Brown missed over a four-year period. ‘She can’t recall one specific day that Rene Brown was not at work so all we’re getting is guesses.’

It is the time for which Brown was paid that has Slatton facing multiple theft counts as prosecutors say she was paying her terminally ill daughter for time she did not work.

Prosecutors have also charged Slatton’s surviving daughter, Gaye Lentz, with getting paid for time she did not work. However, the defense maintains the money was due the employees due to built up sick time and vacation time, adding they believe the fact former District Attorney Dale Potter was the ex-husband of Lentz may have had a hand in the indictments against both her and her mother.

During opening testimony at the county government building Tuesday afternoon, special prosecutor Glenn Funk told the nine-man, five-woman jury that if Pelham’s testimony is correct, then Slatton’s daughter and employee Rene Brown missed at least 580 days of work between 2001 and when she died from cancer on Aug. 1, 2005, negating a defense claim that she had sick days accumulated to cover her missed work time.

Funk said the most sick time she could have accumulated during her county career was around 200 days, meaning the defense’s claim she had 13 days left at the time of her death is wrong. Galligan said putting a hard number to what he believes is a mere guess would carry too much weight in the jury room. Special Judge Allen W. Wallace disagreed and he will allow the 580 days to be considered by the jury.

Funk also pointed out there were no actual records pertaining to sick time at the office as the court was informed such records were missing.

‘I know Joy didn’t keep up with sick time because she told me so,’ Pelham testified.

While saying there were issues between her and Slatton prior to her leaving the trustee’s office in 2006, Pelham said she did not think Slatton ‘would intentionally’ do anything to take money that was not hers.

‘I’ve never known her to lie,’ Pelham said of Slatton, choking back tears as she recalled Brown’s illness.

The defense questioned Pelham’s time frame for Brown’s second bout with cancer which she said started in 2004. The defense maintains it was 2005 and suggested it will call Brown’s husband, Larry Brown, to verify its time frame.

However, Pelham insisted Brown missed a lot of time even during her time of remission between 2002-2004, noting she worked a reduced work schedule but still received full pay. She added Brown would fill out time cards in advance.

Pelham went on to say Lentz continued to get paid after leaving employment at the trustee’s office in 2000 to take another job. Pelham added she knew of no work she did to get the $4,000 prosecutors say she wrongly took, resisting a claim by the defense that Lentz came in after hours. Pelham said at one point, Lentz even wrote herself a check.

‘Gaye asked me to bring the checkbook to her out in the parking lot,’ Pelham recalled, noting she was the one who took Lentz’s old job so she would know if Lentz was performing duties.

In light of Pelham’s testimony, Galligan suggested Pelham would have benefited had Slatton been forced to resign prior to the election, an election in which Pelham was seeking the trustee’s job. Pelham said while not happy with the way she was treated by Slatton, she was not testifying to get even, nor did she believe she would have been in line for the appointment had Slatton resigned before her term was complete.

‘An appointment would have been a real leg up in the upcoming election,’ Galligan noted, pointing out his client served the county since 1978 as trustee. ‘She would not have stolen a nickel from a soul and her daughter would not have gone to meet her maker with this on her.’

Prosecutor Glenn Funk disagrees as he will continue prosecution this morning at 9 a.m. at the county government building.

Leave a Comment