Weakening open meetings law will only hurt citizens
The mayor of Oak Ridge thinks it would be a mistake for three members of his city council to be able to discuss public business in private because it could lead to cliques and dysfunctional government.
“We don’t need that,” Mayor Tom Beehan told The Oak Ridger. His comments were in response to a legislative study committee proposal that the state Sunshine Law would not apply to any meeting unless a quorum is present. Three would be one short of a quorum in Oak Ridge.
The proposal also doesn’t sit well with the chairman of the Anderson County Commission, where a quorum is nine. “I’m not in favor of allowing eight commissioners to meet in secret to discuss issues,” Myron Iwanski told the local paper.
The mayor of Collierville told the Commercial Appeal the push for a change from the present “two or more” members to the quorum would “give the general public the wrong impression.” A Memphis Light Gas & Water board member predicted it “will likely lead to transgressions against what is best for the public.”
Mayor Beehan is in line to chair the Tennessee Municipal League. While not speaking for the TML, his comments and those of other local elected officials make you wonder why associations representing city, county, and school board officials are spending local taxpayer dollars to convince the legislature they the need to talk more about public business in private.
On-the-record dissent reported so far shows that every Tennessean and every newspaper have reason to ask local officials about the change. A statewide poll last year found 56 percent of regular voters already believe more state and local public business is conducted in secret than in the open, confirming the Collierville mayor’s concern.
There are ample reasons to question the timing of the changes. Local governments right now are pushing for legislative authority to adopt new revenue sources, including local payroll taxes.
The association of counties earlier had asked for clarification on what two members of a public body could do in so-called “chance meetings” without it being interpreted as a violation. They and the TML also want to remove “deliberation” from the list of acts prohibited in private meetings.
An injunction imposed by a Knoxville judge last month after the Knox County Commission was found guilty of blatant violations was used to elicit sympathy for local officials from study committee members. Commissioners there used the quorum standard as their defense for a series of secret meetings and discussions used to appoint relatives, handpicked county employees, and political cronies to 12 county offices.
Besides vacating the offices and ordering a public “re-do,” the Knox County judge explained that the only penalty at his disposal was the injunction and the threat of criminal contempt. Local officials have super-imposed the threat of a $50 fine and jail time for a second violation to exaggerate problems under the current law.
If the study panel’s recommendation stands, a group of elected officials, one short of a quorum, can gather in private, reach a consensus, and send someone to a meeting of another small group. All that is necessary is a single vote from the second group and it becomes a done deal without a minute of public discussion. Who counts to see whether a quorum was present?
Without hearing any real evidence of a problem, the study panel has proposed making the loophole larger and with no public resources to challenge expected abuses.
Frank Gibson is executive director of the Tennessee Coalition for Open Government. He can be reached at [email protected].
