Skip to content

Will Region 4-5A get out the brooms?

We pondered it at the halfway point of the high school football season, and now it’s time to ask the question again.

Does Region 3-5A stand a chance in the first round of the playoffs?

The short answer, I’m afraid, is ‘no.’

Not only has the neighboring league dominated the seven inter-region games against Warren County’s league foes this year ‘ with only Lebanon’s loss to Cookeville blemishing the Region 4 record ‘ they’ve made a habit of it in the playoffs, winning 24 of 34 postseason matchups since 2001.

Two of those, you’ll recall, were first-round wins over Warren County by Wilson Central and Riverdale.

Lebanon, the fourth-place finisher from Region 4, takes on the Region 3 champs tonight, and Lincoln County is the only 3-5A team in many football analysts’ opinions which has any legitimate shot at winning ‘ although many are also predicting a Blue Devil upset.

But would it be an upset? Would any win by a Region 4 team be considered a shocker in tonight’s first-round games?

Keep this in mind. Oakland, which finished dead last in the Region 4 standings, was 2-0 this year against Region 3 teams. They shut out Franklin County and defeated Coffee County by two touchdowns.

Would they have won the league title if they were in 3-5A? It’s hard to say, but it’s easy to imagine they’d have been right there in the mix for it for 10 weeks.

Smyrna coach Philip Shadowens, who knows a thing or two about winning football programs, summed it up in an interview with the (Murfreesboro) Daily News Journal’s Jared Hastings.

‘There isn’t a bad team in our region,’ he said. ‘You put every team in our region in a different region across the midstate and they’re playoff teams, which is a shame for some of those that don’t make the playoffs out of our region.’

So a new question arises: Why are the teams from Region 3 so much better?

Mainly, it’s strength of schedule. As an eight-team region, the boys in Rutherford and Wilson Counties have only two non-league games per year. So when the final four emerge as playoff contenders, they’ve had an eight-week tussle on their hands to get to that point.

Preparing for the Smyrnas and Riverdales of the world toughens you up, especially when they hand you your hat for a few seasons. I was on the sideline for a Smyrna-Riverdale game in 1997, when the Warriors won by an outrageous 47-0 margin. The Bulldogs went 4-6 that season, just missing the playoffs, and have improved steadily ever since, going on to knock Riverdale out of the postseason and capturing their first-ever state title a year ago.

But even this year, in region play, the Bulldogs have had their share of tough fights. They barely defeated La Vergne, and lost to a Lebanon team which finished two spots below them in the final region standings.

That’s parity, and parity comes from playing tough competition week in and week out.

And come Week 12 of the 2007 high school football season, fans of midstate gridiron action could see even more of that parity, as all four teams from 4-5A have a legitimate shot at going into the second round and facing off against each other.

Leave a Comment