Skip to content

Geothermal estimate $450K more than expected

City officials took a step back and a deep breath after bids for the Civic Center’s proposed geothermal heating and cooling system came in quite a bit more than expected ‘ $450,000 more.

An audit by Townsend Engineering of Chattanooga estimated the cost of installing a geothermal system to replace the conventional system at $750,000. With the expected savings from an energy audit between $750,000 and $900,000 over the next 25 to 30 years, city officials figured savings over the life of the system would pay for installation.

After receiving two bids ‘ one for the geothermal field and one for the work on the inside of the Civic Center ‘ the combined bid for removal of the old system and installation of the new system was $1.2 million.

CHC Mechanical submitted a bid at $873,000 which would cover all the mechanical on the inside of the Civic Center, and Mid State Construction bid $348,092 on outside geothermal installation.

The large difference between what was estimated and the actual bid is being attributed to unexpected work.

‘We went into some detailed questioning as to why it was that much higher,’ said Parks and Recreation director Carlene Brown. ‘What the engineer told us was that the estimate was done based on tonnage. When they actually got in here and drew the plans, that is when they found out the detail and complexity of the project.’

Given the bids, officials will have to decide if they want to move forward with a geothermal system or change direction and go with a conventional system. There will be problems with either decision.

If officials move forward with geothermal, extra funding will have to be obtained to pay the unexpected $450,000. Moving forward would most likely increase the annual payment amount which was set at $120,000 in the 2007-2008 budget.

A conventional system is estimated at $340,000. Changing from geothermal to conventional would mean the project would have to be bid out again. If that is done, the city would probably lose the $500,000 interest-free energy loan that was given specifically for the installation of geothermal.

Officials have instructed Brown to ask CHC Mechanical if it would give a cost estimate as to how much they believe a conventional system would be. If they do not, the project will have to be bid out to determine exact cost.

City administrator David Rutherford is working on additional funding for the geothermal system if officials chose that direction.

When all the information is received, officials will have to decide which direction to move. Until then, the Civic Center is in a wait-and-see mode, and will have to utilize the two of the 14 units on the roof that still work.

Leave a Comment