Government and secrets don’t mix
Like most folks, I have several quirks, some of which are more pronounced than others. At the top of my list of oddball beliefs is the fact I feel our government should not conduct official business in secret.
This pertains to local government, like the McMinnville Board of Mayor and Aldermen, and the Warren County Commission. It pertains to state government such as the Tennessee General Assembly, and it also includes national government like Congress.
It seems like such a straightforward request. Since our elected officials are in fact elected by the people to serve the people, they should make their decisions in full view of the people.
I realize I’m drunk with ideology when I make such a statement. Instead of operating in the open, government officials always tend to gravitate toward the idea of operating behind closed doors.
This naturally makes me suspicious. I guess it’s the same principle that makes me strain my ears to hear what two people are whispering about in the corner. Meanwhile I try to block out a really loud conversation, especially when it’s a guy standing behind me talking on his cellphone.
I say all this for reasons other than hearing myself type. Earlier this week, members of a Tennessee legislative committee voted to relax the state’s Sunshine Law. At its current strength, the Sunshine Law prohibits two or more elected officials from the same governing body from discussing official business in private.
It’s a sound and sensible law, but one that’s nearly impossible to enforce. Who is to know if two city aldermen call each other after hours to discuss how they’re going to vote? How can you stop three or four county commissioners from talking about county business over coffee?
You can’t. And sadly, members of the media are the only ones who seem to care about the Sunshine Law in the first place.
The proposed change in the Sunshine Law, as voted on earlier this week, will allow up to a quorum of any board or commission to meet in private without inviting citizens. The change has to be approved by the General Assembly next year.
Quite frankly, such a change in the Sunshine Law could be disastrous. It’s already a law that lacks any teeth. Elected officials who choose to abide by the law only do so by choice. There’s no e-mail Gestapo out there monitoring what elected officials say online.
Adding fuel to the proverbial fire is the fact this Sunshine Law talk comes during the same week it was revealed the White House significantly edited testimony prepared for a Senate hearing on the impact of global warming. From what I can gather, this means the White House determined senators don’t need to know about the six pages of diseases and health problems that might flourish if Earth continues to warm.
The report, by the way, was one delivered by the director of the Centers for Disease Control.
Much like elected officials who try to bypass open meetings, this was a clear case of government trying to keep the public in the dark. I don’t see anything positive that comes from censoring information that was prepared for Congress. It’s both sneaky and misleading.
As long as government continues to operate with tax dollars ‘ and it always will ‘ elected officials have an obligation to keep the people they represent informed. That ideal should never change, regardless of who is in office.
James Clark is editor of the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].
