Prosecutors define case against Mathis
Prosecutors will say former daycare owner Sherri Mathis strangled 6-year-old Cheyenne Delp to death when they try her for murder next year in the oft-delayed case.
The announcement was made during pre-trial hearings for the scheduled February trial. Prior to the announcement, a dual theory of the child’s death had existed, with prosecutors holding open the possibility they would also seek a murder conviction for Mathis incorrectly dispensing medication for the child.
Mathis is charged with strangling the 6-year-old ward of the court to death in their King’s Point home in the summer of 2004. Prosecutors say there was a pattern of abuse concerning not only Delp, but her two brothers who they claim were also choked by Mathis.
The defense maintains Delp had medical problems and may have died from the toxic combinations of medicines in her system. They claim Mathis tried to save the girl’s life when she suffered the fatal medical attack and that there were no signs of strangulation.
The state has suggested that if poisoning from her prescription drugs was the cause of death then it was still Mathis’ responsibility because she was the one who gave the girl the medications. Prosecutors have apparently scrapped the idea of using poisoning as an alternative means of murder given their announcement. Prosecutors have also said they do not intend to use a particular weapon as being used in the strangulation death.
Meanwhile, the defense is expected to use either the theory of a toxic combination of medicines or death by other medical causes, neither coming at the hands of Delp’s caregiver.
‘We may offer an alternative cause of death,’ defense attorney Michael Galligan told Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley.
Additional motions in the case are set for Dec. 7 at 1 p.m. Mathis remains free on bond.
