If car breaks down, you still have to pay
DEAR BRUCE: Two years ago, my daughter purchased a 1994 van. She had to get full coverage on the vehicle because she was still paying for it. The van cost $3,600, and she still owes $1,600. She took it in for maintenance, and the garage installed a new gearbox — which had to be replaced for a second time. When she pulled out of my yard recently, she heard a pinging noise. She got out and looked under the hood. The gearbox had broken away from the frame, creating a big hole. The entire front end had collapsed — it’s no more than six inches off the ground. Does she have a legal leg to stand on when it comes to paying for this van? It can never be driven again. She is worried that the bank will still want their money, even if the van is a total loss. What is the best way to handle this? — J.W., via e-mail
DEAR J.W.: Let’s separate things quickly. Your daughter is concerned that the bank will want to be paid. Well, of course it will. The fact that the van is not worth a dime does not in any way diminish your daughter’s responsibility by a penny. The fact that the collateral on the loan is worthless is another story. They have nothing to repossess. But they can still come after your daughter, as they should. The next question: Can the maintenance company be held responsible for the damage? If she can demonstrate that their carelessness or incompetence caused the damage, the garage may have some responsibility. Someone will have to testify to this, such as a mechanic. Her best course would be to discuss the situation with the company that did the work and, if they disavow any responsibility, small-claims court is the next step. Make no mistake, the full coverage has nothing to do with this, and the fact that she owes money to the bank is in no way diminished because of the condition of her car.
DEAR BRUCE: Three years ago, my husband and I refinanced our home to procure some cash to start a business. The loans have a prepayment penalty of six months’ interest if paid within the three-year-note anniversary. The first lien is an ARM, with adjustable rates starting in the third year. The second lien is a balloon due within 15 years. The three-year anniversary is March 23, 2008. Should we wait until then to refinance, or should we refinance now and get hit with the penalty? What is our best move? — R.E., via e-mail
DEAR R.E.: Six months’ interest is a severe penalty and acknowledging that the three-year anniversary is fast approaching, I think that would be the time to refinance. There is nothing to prevent you from looking for a more favorable financing arrangement now, but understand that, with the chaos in the mortgage market, this may be a painful experience. You haven’t outlined the terms of the balloon that is due in 15 years, but unless it’s an extraordinarily high rate of interest, it is not an immediate concern. The ARM very likely will be going up considerably next March. You should be shopping now for a refinance to begin on March 23, 2008.
DEAR BRUCE: In 1998, my mother made a quitclaim deed. The lawyer who drew it up has since died. My sister and I were named on it and then she died. My sister had two children and a granddaughter, but they are not named on the deed. Will I have to share the house with them, or is the deed dead like the lawyer who drew it up? — S.M., via e-mail
DEAR S.M.: It is easy enough to find out whether this was recorded — as it should have been. A visit to your county seat can determine this. The property should be properly recorded as belonging to you and your sister. Upon the execution of the quitclaim, the home became yours and your sister’s. Other relatives have no claim on this property. But since your sister has passed, her relatives will no doubt have an interest in the property.
DEAR BRUCE: My friend sold me universal-life insurance, with $250,000 coverage for my son when he was a year-old; the yearly payment is $1,025, and I have made two payments already. The insurance is for his college fund, but I have a feeling it’s not as good as a 529 plan; the fees are just too high. If I close the universal life, I will lose all the money, since the cash value is still zero. Should I keep the insurance, or just close it and open a 529 instead? Am I going to accumulate more money in a 529 or universal-life account in the next 15 years? Since I have two sons, I can’t afford to keep this policy and open a 529. — L.H., via e-mail
DEAR L.H.: First of all, you say your “friend” sold you the universal-life policy. I would question his friendship since, in my view, this is not an appropriate investment: $250,000 for an infant is absurd. While the cost may be modest, in my opinion, the money is being thrown away. There are many 529 plans available through the various states, and some are better than others. Understand that the designers of 529s are responsible to politicians. Since they are sensitive to the possibility of failure, the returns on 529s, although tax sensitive, often are not anywhere near as generous as those of more conventional investments. I am reluctant to tell anyone to cancel life insurance, but at this early date, your friend has made his commission and you will take a hit — but I would still do so. You might wish to consider a well-thought-out mutual fund in you and your husband’s name. There will be some tax liability when it comes time for college; on the other hand, if the kid doesn’t go to college, the money is yours without the penalty attached to a 529 that is not used directly for college expenses.
DEAR BRUCE: I inherited an annuity of $19,000 when my grandmother died. When I cashed in, no one asked whether I wanted to have taxes withheld. When I did my taxes this year, I really took a hit and now have to make payments to the IRS for the $4,000 I still owe. I make $54,000 a year. I can’t itemize because I don’t own much of anything. Is there anything I can do to ease the IRS burden? — S.H., via e-mail
DEAR S.H.: You say you received this annuity when your grandmother died. Was the annuity considered part of your grandmother’s estate? If so, any taxes due on the $19,000 should have been paid by the estate. Your only tax liability would be the accrued earnings on the $19,000 after the death. You say when “you did your taxes.” Have an accountant look over your tax return. You may have erred in the filing, and there may be little or no tax due.
DEAR BRUCE: I would like to have a better understanding of savings bonds. I have a 13-year-old son and a 4-month-old granddaughter. The bonds would be for them. What exactly are savings bonds, and how do I purchase them? Thank you for all your valuable information. — R.M., Oakland, Calif.
DEAR R.M.: U.S. savings bonds are simply a mechanism for the government to borrow money from its citizens. The interest rates vary, but the proceeds are fully taxable unless purchased for children, with limits on the parents’ income, and used for college expenses. One great thing about savings bonds: the low initial purchase price. These can be purchased at any bank or savings institution.
