Skip to content

Twenty-one people were sentenced this past week by Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley. Included in circuit court sentencings:

Twenty-one people were sentenced this past week by Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley. Included in circuit court sentencings:

WHITE
Though she denies any wrongdoing, a Minnesota woman has been slapped with a court order to pay damages to record companies for illegal downloading and sharing of copyrighted music over the Internet ‘ to the tune of $222,000.

Jammie Thomas, of Brainerd, Minn., was recently ordered by a federal jury to pay $9,250 for each of 24 songs which jurors found her guilty of distributing via a file-sharing Web site called Kazaa.

The reaction of the recording industry to file-sharing has been universally negative, with industry executives claiming the practice is costing the companies literally millions of dollars in lost revenues. The industry is fighting this growing problem in the courts, with over 26,000 lawsuits filed since 2003. Many of the defendants have settled out of court for a few thousand dollars. The suit against Thomas is the first to go to trial and is, by far, the largest financial levy against an offender up to this point.

The distribution of music over the Internet isn’t new. Such file-sharing began a heated public debate when the first heavily-trafficked file-sharing service, Napster, went online in 1999. Napster was eventually shut down, but the debate raged on as similar services, commonly called peer-to-peer networks (P2P), sprang up in its stead.

Those who advocate file-sharing offer compelling arguments that the practice has not harmed album sales, while opponents argue with equal vehemence that it has.

The problem here is that many of these works are copyrighted, and it is the unauthorized ‘sharing’ of these protected materials that has caused the controversy.

But even though most P2P users know this practice can conceivably get them in trouble, it hasn’t slowed them down, and in fact the activity appears to be on the increase.

One local resident, who understandably wishes to remain anonymous, has been downloading music since the Napster days, and says he doesn’t really see anything wrong with it.

‘I’ve purchased most of the music I share,’ he said, ‘and the person who shares with me has probably done so as well. Besides, the record companies have been ripping us off for years with high-priced CDs. I heard it costs about a dollar to produce and package a CD, and then they charge us upwards of $20 for some of the new releases. I don’t want to cheat the artists, but you can be pretty sure they aren’t getting much of that anyway.’

This consumer says he also utilizes online music stores like iTunes and Rhapsody, paying the standard $1.99 per song.

‘I probably buy more songs than I download,’ he said. ‘A lot of the ones I download aren’t available on the online music stores. They are from more obscure groups that you don’t hear about too often. And even some major groups, like ACDC, don’t sell their music online.’

Some artists and songwriters have mixed feelings about the trend. Songwriter Jack White, who is well-known to Warren County residents, and just appeared at the Dottie West Music Fest, is one of those. He says he feels the damages assessed against people like Thomas is excessive.

‘I think that most people in the music business do not realize how helpful the Internet has been,’ White said. ‘As far as bringing all types of music and artists to people. Of course, I also think, because it is intellectual property, there ought to be a price, but there should never any punitive retribution that’s visited on just ordinary, everyday lovers of music.

‘What they’re doing with that, is they’re hurting their art, they’re hurting the very people who support their industry,’ White said. ‘We live in a country where ‘music business’ is two words. When you forget that it really is the music, God gives us this beautiful music, you ought to want to share that as much as you can. I just believe that there is something that can be done, but just not that extreme.’

White’s friend, and Dottie West Music Fest co-organizer, Thomas B. Vaughn, says the practice is potentially damaging to artists, despite what some may think.

‘The one thing that everybody needs to remember is that for every successful singer/songwriter, like you saw on the stage at the music fest, there are thousands, and probably hundreds of thousands, of struggling singers and songwriters trying to make a living,’ Vaughn said. ‘The only means for them to make a living is the production of intellectual property. And their material, whether they are singers or songwriters, that’s their intellectual property,’ Vaughn added.

‘Now you wouldn’t go over to Applebees and steal meals to share with your friends. You’d pay for those meals. That’s the thing that’s hard for a lot of people to understand. You should pay for that intellectual property, it isn’t free.’

But even though he has strong feelings about stealing intellectual property, like White, Vaughn thinks record companies may be going to far, particularly in the Thomas case.

‘There is a balance,’ Vaughn said. ‘I think common sense has to come into play there. Maybe she was the victim of overzealous prosecution, I don’t know about that. But I do know this, intellectual property deserves to be protected by the law, and is protected by the law, so people need to understand that.’

Leave a Comment