Skip to content

Religious right headed in wrong direction

The religious right-wing nuts are at it again.??After making their considerable clout felt in the 2000 and 2004 presidential elections, some of their leaders now want to dictate who the 2008 Republican presidential nominee will be.

These leaders are quick to judge the current crop of Republican front-runners and to find them severely lacking.??They find Rudy Giuliani especially unacceptable, largely because of his views on abortion and gay marriage, plus his own multiple marriages.??So far, they aren’t all that happy with any of the other Republican candidates either. ??

Apparently, some of the key religious right leaders, notably Texas preacher Rick Scarborough and radio talk show host James Dobson think the answer to their current dilemma is to bolt the Republican Party in favor of some ill-defined third party movement.

The problem with this kind of thinking is at least twofold.??First, it smacks of extreme self-righteousness, which suggests the religious right leaders are the sole arbiters of right and wrong. Such exclusionary thinking ignores the pluralistic religious nature of American culture and history.??

Our First Amendment freedoms guarantee us both freedom of religion and freedom from religion.??James Madison and his colleagues knew first-hand the tyranny of church-state fusion.??They took great pains to create a climate of church-state separation as the blueprint for the future of the fledgling American republic.

Second, the threat to form a third party is an empty one, with potentially disastrous results for Republicans in 2008 and beyond. If Mr. Dobson and Mr. Scarborough would digress from their demagoguery long enough to study a little secular history, they might just ferret out the obvious:??Third parties don’t win presidential elections.??

Instead, they often produce unintended consequences.??Just ask Al Gore, current Nobel Prize winner and former ‘next President of the United States.’ Arguably, Ralph Nader and his band of left-wing nuts spoiled Gore’s chances of winning the White House.??Maybe.??Maybe not.

The better case study for the folly of third party alternatives could be the tumultuous presidential elections of 1912.??Former President Theodore Roosevelt, also a Nobel Peace Prize winner, was so disappointed in his successor, President William Taft, that he challenged him for the party nomination.??When that failed, Roosevelt bolted the Republican Party to lead the Progressives in a deeply divisive debacle that guaranteed the victory of Democrat Woodrow Wilson. ??

When the results of the 1912 presidential general elections were in, Wilson was the clear victor where it counted [and still does].?? He won 435 electoral votes to Roosevelt’s 88 and Taft’s mere 8. Moreover, the Republican split was a factor in Wilson’s re-election in 1916.

So, if the goal of the religious right-wing nuts is to ignore history and lead their flock, lemming-like, over the cliff and into third party irrelevance, they’re on the right track.?? However, the unintended consequences of their self-righteous arrogance may well be the election of their worst enemy, Hillary Rodham Clinton and the further demise of the once mighty GOP.

Thomas B. Vaughn is an instructor at Motlow College and co-host of the radio show ‘Viewpoints,’ which airs on WCPI 91.3 FM.

Leave a Comment