Johnson uses 3 identities in failed scam, detective says
A local man faces theft charges after he allegedly posed under three separate identities to trick a well-meaning woman to collect money for him. The woman thought she was helping him raise money to bury a mutual friend.
‘This was a well-meaning girl who got taken advantage of,’ said sheriff’s investigator Jackie Matheny Jr. ‘This guy basically had her collecting money under false pretenses, using her trust for profit.’
The defendant, Steven Utah Johnson, 31, is charged with one count of misdemeanor theft since the entire amount collected and given to him amounted to around $300. However, additional charges could be coming at a later date since Johnson allegedly presented himself fraudulently to the woman in hopes of making illegal financial gain.
According to Matheny, the chain of events which led to Johnson’s arrest began when a person identifying himself as Stephen Johnson started speaking with the victim on the phone. Johnson got her number despite the fact they had never met.
The pair struck up a friendship over the phone, talking on several occasions until the woman was contacted one day, by a person calling himself ‘Gavin’ using the same cellphone. Gavin said Johnson had been killed in California and he was a friend who was trying to raise money to bring him back to Warren County for burial.
During the conversation, Gavin asked the victim to help raise money for their mutual friend’s burial, something the victim did willingly. It was at that point the woman put out three collection jars at local businesses and also had her church donate money to the cause. Then, as instructed by Gavin, the woman took the proceeds to the man he identified as Stephen Johnson’s brother, a man named Utah. Unknown to the victim, Utah is Stephen Johnson’s middle name.
It was during the delivery of some of the money that she finally met the man identified as Utah. The two had conversations together when she would deliver money. In addition to the burial, Utah had convinced her to help raise money for a cousin of his who had cancer.
However, during one of the conversations between Utah and the victim, the suspect referred several times to himself as Stephen. When questioned, the suspect ‘he had missed Stephen and had called himself that a lot lately.’
The slip was enough to make the victim suspect something was amiss, especially given the fact all three people, Stephen, Gavin and Utah, had called her from the same cellphone and also given the fact she had only seen one of them.
During questioning by lawmen, Johnson refused to admit conning the victim, instead saying it was a misunderstanding.
‘Well, unless he can produce the other two men and maybe a death certificate, I’m convinced he did this alone, especially when she said that the voices sounded similar when she had talked to them on the phone,’ said Matheny, noting Johnson’s version of events are highly questionable.
Johnson is due for preliminary hearing before General Sessions Judge Larry Ross on Nov. 20.
