Skip to content

Iraq should at least be a lesson

“Mistaken ideas always end in bloodshed, but in every case it is someone else’s blood. That is why some of our thinkers feel free to say just about anything.” — Albert Camus

Even as the disaster unravels, many Americans simply refuse to learn anything significant from Iraq. Never mind the White House; it’s long been clear that George W. Bush’s mind is an impenetrable fortress. The man has no ideas, only beliefs. Facts and arguments at odds with those beliefs are simply rejected. This president is incapable of learning. The GOP dead-enders supporting him, roughly 30 percent of the electorate, have recast themselves in his image. They may as well call themselves, as Walker Percy suggested in “Love in the Ruins,” the Knotheads.

The rest of us need to move along without them. That’s the first lesson of Iraq. Back in 2000, many who should have known better found Bush’s feckless arrogance charming. The United States was so economically and militarily powerful, they figured any well-connected nonentity could be president. Astride the world like a colossus, America could basically run itself.

The next president will require the intellect to learn from experience, the self-confidence to tolerate dissent, and the strength to admit mistakes. So will we citizens. That’s why I find the current debate about “neoconservatism” so appallingly stupid.

Because the second lesson of Iraq is that American military power is not unlimited. It was self-described neoconservatives who persuaded Bush to make a disastrous strategic blunder in the “war on terror,” wasting blood and treasure in Iraq rather than finishing the job of taking down Osama bin Laden.

Now they whine that the term has become “shorthand for neocon-Zionist conspiracy … to exploit Iraqi oil, bomb Iran and apply U.S. power to Israel’s benefit.” According to Roger Cohen in The New York Times, “neocon has morphed into an all-purpose insult for anyone who still believes that American power is inextricable from global stability.”

Two things you won’t find in Cohen’s column: the actual names of these alleged anti-Semites or the word “Afghanistan.” That’s because nobody you ever heard of subscribes to such cartoonish views. As Michael Tomasky points out in The Guardian, Cohen’s screed ignores “liberals who are neither hawks nor on the left. People who, for example, supported the U.S. invasion of Afghanistan. People who, for that matter, supported the interventions of the 1990s,” i.e. Bosnia and Kosovo.

Tomasky lists public intellectuals who took these positions: Paul Krugman, Eric Alterman, Mark Danner, John Judis, etc. He doesn’t say so, but many are themselves Jews, like many prominent neoconservatives.

Heeding neoconservatives has got the United States simultaneously losing two wars — Afghanistan and Iraq — even as they lead cheers to attack a third country, Iran, larger than the other two combined. Osama bin Laden can only dream of such madness. A surer formula for military and political meltdown can hardly be imagined.

But don’t take my word for it. Log on to the Project for a New American Century Web site, and read the neocons founding statement: a sweeping plan for never-ending war from the Mediterranean to the Himalayas that reads like something concocted by a James Bond villain. Or simply ponder the words of leading (non-Jewish) neoconservative Kanan Mikaya, spoken in 2002 about the odds of establishing democracy in Iraq: “I think there’s a less than 5 percent chance that what I’d like to see happen actually happens … But it seems to me an obligation, even if it’s a 5 percent chance, to try to make it happen. You could call it a triumph of hope over experience.”

Alternatively, you could simply call it crazy.

Arkansas Democrat-Gazette columnist Gene Lyons can be reached at [email protected].

Leave a Comment