Critics say children’s videos don’t help learning process
But do these enormously popular and profitable videos and DVDs devised for viewers too young even to sit up provide educational enrichment, as supporters contend? Or are they a skillful marketing scheme for products that may impede cognitive development, as critics say?
Those questions have been reignited by a highly publicized study by veteran child development researchers at the University of Washington.
The Seattle team surveyed more than 1,000 families in February 2006 and found that infants between 8 and 16 months who regularly watched Baby Einstein and Brainy Baby videos knew substantially fewer words ‘ six to eight out of 90 ‘ than infants who did not watch them, according to parental reports. The deficit, which increased with each hour of video viewing, was not seen among babies who watched other programming, such as ‘Sesame Street’ or ‘SpongeBob SquarePants’ or adult shows such as ‘Oprah.’
The study, published in the Journal of Pediatrics, is the first to examine the impact of videos that have been heavily promoted as educational, according to lead author Frederick J. Zimmerman, a University of Washington associate professor of public health and pediatrics. Zimmerman called the negative effect ‘large and significant’ but said the study stopped short of establishing a causal connection.
‘Parents should not panic,’ Zimmerman said. Fifteen minutes of video viewing, he said, is unlikely to matter. But some babies in their study watched as much as four hours per day ‘ a circumstance facilitated by the automatic replay feature on Baby Einstein DVDs.
In Zimmerman’s view, parents have been ‘misled’ about the benefits of baby videos, which can displace real-world parent-child interaction and creative play, both known to be essential for cognitive development.
Other experts agree. No empirical study, they say, has demonstrated benefits for any video or television programming in children younger than 2. That is the chief reason the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) advises no screen time for this age group, a recommendation that experts concede is widely ignored. Studies have linked heavy TV viewing among children older than 3 to attention and learning problems, sleep disturbances and obesity.
Earlier this year, researchers reported that 20 percent of children younger than 2 had a television set in their bedroom. Another study by Zimmerman’s team found that 40 percent of 3-month-olds regularly watched an hour per day, a figure that rose to 90 percent by age 2.
A decade ago, programming aimed at infants and toddlers was virtually nonexistent. Since then, videos, DVDs, affiliated books and toys and even a 24-hour cable TV channel called BabyFirst TV have emerged, creating an industry with annual revenue estimated to exceed $1 billion.
‘These videos are incredibly seductive and hit parents where they are most vulnerable: fears about academic success and intense time pressures,’ said educational psychologist Susan Linn, co-founder of the advocacy group Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood and an instructor in psychiatry at Harvard Medical School.
Last year the campaign, with the support of the AAP and the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry (AACAP), filed a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission against Baby Einstein and Brainy Baby, alleging that they engaged in false and deceptive advertising. At issue were claims by the manufacturers that the videos promote language skills, foster infant development or provide ‘a jump-start on learning.’ The matter has not been resolved.
‘The hype that these are educational makes parents feel less guilty about sticking their kids in front of the tube,’ said Washington area psychiatrist Michael Brody, who chairs the AACAP’s committee on media.
Makers of baby videos dispute such criticism. They dismiss Zimmerman’s study as methodologically flawed and point out that the language gap was not seen in infants between 17 and 24 months.
Brainy Baby chief executive Dennis Fedoruk said in an e-mail that his Atlanta-based company’s videos are ‘tools that parents can use with their children, much like a book, to introduce academic basics.’
Fedoruk said he has received ‘thousands of unsolicited testimonials from customers who have seen a positive result in their own children from watching our videos,’ including improved scores on an IQ test.
