Jury finds Hale guilty of murder – He faces 15-25 as self-defense strategy fails
|
A jury convicted Hale on Wednesday of second-degree murder for the gunfight which claimed the life of Van Buren County Commissioner John Scott.
Hale, who is being held awaiting sentencing before Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley on Nov. 26, faces 15 to 25 years in prison. The charge was the top felony on which he could have been convicted.
The jury’s verdict came after Hale decided not to testify on his own behalf, leaving his fate in the hands of jurors after they heard a full day of testimony Tuesday, mainly brought by the prosecution. The defense brought a single witness to the stand.
During trial, evidence was presented that it was Hale who was actually shot first in the gun battle which happened outside a convenience store near Spencer in 2004. A witness said Hale approached Scott’s vehicle and tried to grab him through his partially lowered window. Scott then opened fire, hitting Hale once in the midsection.
Hale staggered to the truck in which he was riding, pulled his 44 Magnum, and fired four shots, two of which struck Scott in the leg after passing through his door.
Forensic pathologist Dr. Thomas Deering testified the shots shattered both of Scott’s femurs and also ruptured his femoral artery, causing him to bleed to death. First-responders said Scott’s veins were flat when they got there, suggesting he had lost large quantities of blood, as they were unable to insert an I.V. into his arms.
Hale was also seriously injured and was treated for the wound to his midsection. It was during their flight from the shooting scene that the driver of the vehicle in which he was a passenger, Jason Smith, told Hale he had ‘messed up’ by returning fire.
‘I meant that he could have left without anyone else getting hurt,’ Smith said of his statement to Hale as his friend was waiting for an ambulance minutes after the shooting.
While the defense maintained the meeting was a chance encounter at the station, special prosecutor Tommy Thompson said prosecutors believe the meeting was no accident.
Prosecutors told jurors that earlier that same day Scott was charged with beating local auto parts dealer Robert Hastings over a business deal, an incident which did not sit well with Hale, who was mad the much younger Scott had jumped the 62-year-old businessman.
‘He had said something about going to Scott’s home,’ testified Hastings’ son Matt Hastings of Hale’s statement earlier in the afternoon. ‘He (Mr. Hastings) had told us to just leave it alone, that he had taken a warrant out on him for assault.’
Adding doubt to the fact it was a chance encounter was a motorist who testified he saw the truck in which Hale was riding do a U-turn and fall in behind him when they passed him on Highway 111, following him to the store.
Charges were dismissed against Smith, who was charged along with Hale for the murder. The special prosecutor said he found no proof Smith was involved in the crime.

