Gwyn wants field officers to retire at 60
Tennessee Bureau of Investigation director Mark Gwyn paid a visit to his hometown Tuesday to discuss retirement options for post-certified law enforcement personnel under new state legislation.
In attendance were a number of local law enforcement officers who would be directly affected by the legislation if the county opts to adopt it.
Specifically, Gwyn talked about SB 0332/HB 0464, a bill he helped push through the state legislature this year that set mandatory retirement ages at the state level for officers of the Department of Safety (state troopers), TBI, wildlife officers and officers of the Alcoholic Beverage Commission, but also offered expanded and improved retirement benefits.
Mandatory retirement will be age 60, with the exception of department heads, such as police chiefs and sheriffs. If more than 50 percent of job duties are in an administrative or supervisory capacity, the mandatory retirement age is deferred to age 62.
At the local level, the legislation would affect sheriff’s officers in counties, and police officers and firefighters in municipalities.
Information provided to the county on how the new law works states that, in general, under this legislation a member in the retirement plan of these agencies is eligible to retire on service retirement benefits at any age with 30 years of service, or at age 60 with five years of service. Alternatively, a member may retire on a reduced (early) retirement benefit upon attaining age 55 or with 25 years of service. In addition, members covered by mandatory retirement at age 60 are also entitled to an additional bridge benefit until the onset of Social Security benefits at age 62.
The provisions are optional for local governments. In other words, unless the local government agrees to accept the liability and cost associated with these provisions, employees are not subject to the mandatory retirement provisions, nor are they entitled to the expanded benefits or bridge benefits.
Gwyn pointed out the bill is aimed specifically at public safety officers because of the stress and physically demanding nature of their jobs, noting he personally helped move the bill through the legislature because he felt something needed to be done, both for public safety and the safety of officers.
‘I felt like something desperately needed to be done about the retirement system,’ Gwyn said, ‘because the dynamics of law enforcement have changed in the past 10 to 15 years. To be quite honest with you, and this is my opinion for what it’s worth, law enforcement has turned into a young man’s game. The days of people working in law enforcement into their 60s and 70s I think is gone. I think the stress is too high, and I think the danger is too high.’
Gwyn acknowledged that there would be questions as to why the new benefits should affect only public safety personnel, such as law enforcement and firefighters, and not other employees.
‘I know you, as commissioners, when you study this thing may ask why should I put money out to do this for these employees over anybody else,’ Gwyn said. ‘Well, I’m going to tell you why. I personally believe the first responsibility of any government of a civilized society, whether it’s federal, state or local, is the protection of its citizens, and this goes to the protection of your citizens.’
Gwyn pointed out that in order to attract the best law enforcement employees possible, the county needs to be able to offer the best benefits possible.
And according to Gwyn, the new system should pay off fiscally as well, in the long run, because it would cost less to hire younger officers to replace older officers who have topped out on salary and benefits if they are allowed to retire early.
Still, some commissioners wondered how older officers felt about the new law. Commissioner Bill Yancy asked some of the law enforcement officers present to comment on the legislation.
‘There may be some of these guys here who don’t want to retire at 60,’ Yancy said. ‘I’d like to hear what they have to say about this.’
Chief sheriff’s investigator Herb Rowland expressed his support for the legislation, noting he appreciated the expanded benefits and the financial security they offered.
‘I’m 63 years old and I’ve been a police officer here for 37 years,’ Rowland said. ‘And I’d like to go to the house, but I can’t afford to.’
Sheriff’s investigator Jim Hartman, who is 60, acknowledged the stresses these jobs entail and how they affect older personnel.
‘I’m not as good as I used to be, and I’m the first one to know that,’ Hartman said. ‘No one has to tell me that I’m not as sharp or as fast or as stout as these young men on the road out here now.’
Hartman said he realizes full well that the average 60-year-old doesn’t have the stamina or speed of the typical 25- to 30-year-old, particularly when it comes to a physical battle or a drawn-out foot chase.
It will be some time before this legislation will be presented to local governments for approval. Even though the state has passed it, Budget and Finance Committee chairman George Smartt said it will require careful study before commissioners vote on it.
‘For one thing, we need to find out how much this is going to cost us locally before we can make any kind of decision on it,’ Smartt said.
