Rooftop railing likely to stay – Restaurant owner gains apparent victory over Historic Commission
Checkmate! Despite what move the Historic Zoning Commission makes next, it looks as if the notorious wood railing placed on the roof of a downtown business is there to stay.
Almost three months ago, New York Grill owner Scott Garing placed what he described as a ‘safety rail’ along the roof of his business. He was asked to stop work until he obtained a Certificate of Appropriateness from the Historic Zoning Commission.
The order to stop work was issued because there were no pictures, sketches or materials presented to the commission by Garing. Therefore, the commission’s decision was deferred until that material was received.
During Monday night’s meeting, Garing once again had no information requested by the commission. Instead, he pointed out that all the information commission members needed to make their decision was published in the Southern Standard, along with a picture of the railing, so he felt nothing else was needed.
Between the last discussion and this one, it was brought to the commission’s attention that the railing would block the historic Dr Pepper sign located on the wall directly behind the rail. The sign was scheduled to be repainted as part of the county’s bicentennial celebration.
The commission once again asked Garing if he would be willing to at least move the safety railing back away from the edge of the building. Moving the railing back would help preserve the historic feel of downtown and preserve the sign, commission members said.
‘Absolutely not,’ said Garing. ‘Not 10 feet or 12 feet. Absolutely not.’
With the discussion once again going nowhere, Garing asked about city ordinances pertaining to the railing. The only ordinance regarding railings is one that requires a railing more the 30 inches off the ground if there is an existing deck.
‘That’s the answer,’ said Garing. ‘Thank you very much. For the record that is a deck, 30 by 30.’
This was news to commission members who were not informed of a deck during the last meeting. If indeed a deck exists, codes requires a railing. This situation leaves the commission in a no-win situation.
‘Here is my opinion, if you want my opinion,’ said Planning and Zoning director Jim Brock. ‘I don’t see any need in carrying this on and on. It is still going to come out the same if you vote for it or against it. I think we should put it to rest and let codes take over.’
The commission’s decision was once again deferred to allow codes time to check on the existence of a deck and where the deck is located. If the deck does exist, the railing must be around the perimeter of the deck and not around the perimeter of the building.
